Recently among the auth we've been talking about access and usage of certain commands on the Showdown Server. However, after the most recent discussion we saw it fit to leave the decision to you, the users most impacted by them.
We're considering access to three commands: /kick, /redirect, and /warn.
/kick is a command that removes a person from the room. With /setkick, it can display silly or cool custom messages for each auth. Because the user can rejoin immediately, it has no disciplinary use, and with /setkick has been left strictly as a command for auth to have fun with, provided it is not abused.
/redirect sends a user from their current room into a new one. It is mostly used to send a player to a place where their conversation is more appropriate. They can still rejoin the old room at any time.
/warn displays a pop up with all of showdown's rules and a message from the auth about what they did wrong. It's an effective tool in helping new users learn the expectations of the community.
/kick is in question to be removed outright. The other two are potentially being revoked from driver status (%). Drivers on Reborn are different from other servers, in that they are staff, but they are not expected to moderate the server, and have very few tools to do so (in fact, just redirect and warn). They mostly have the rank for status and access to the staff room.
Below are the arguments for each option of access of each command:
/kick
All auth: Since kick has no disciplinary application, there's no harm in letting people play around with it. Users should understand it's not an actual punishment, just good fun. Case handlers exist to deal with mods who abuse the privelege, so the risk of expanding it so all auth can use it is negligible, and serves to put them on more equal footing.
@ and higher: The status quo. Abuse cases exist for mods, but there's no reason to increase the risk of abuse by expanding access to the command.
Remove /kick: Fun at others' expense isn't good fun. It's not fair to users if they can be kicked even if it just for laughs, with no permanent consequence, and they could report it as abuse. It's better just to remove the option so that there's no problems in the first place.
/redirect
Yes: Yes, drivers should keep redirect, as they already have it. There's no harm in allowing them to help out with server moderation with something non-serious like redirect.
No: No, drivers should not keep redirect. It's effectively the same as /kick, and it's not their place to moderate the server.
/warn
Yes: Yes, drivers should keep warn, as they already have it. There's no harm in allowing them to help out with server moderation by informing others of the rules with /warn.
No: No, drivers should not keep warn. Drivers' role is not to enforce server moderation, so there's no need for them to use this.
This poll will remain open for one week.