I'm personally of the opinion that, liking a character that is falwed etc... is fine so long as you understand the shit they are doing is NOT okay by any means. Often, characters that are flawed etc people look up or take as examples of ways to be, which tends to not be the the point of the writing of said character.
I do like the mention or allusion to the trope of "He who slays monsters" since due to my limited knowledge of the character, seems to be easily where Titania slots as a character. She is hardly a good person, narratively I find her quite interesting from what I've seen and read on the forums having not played the game, however, as a person... her behavior is quite appalling. She as a person is not a good one despite her intentions to be so. And I think this dichotomy makes her very interesting to people.
Anti-Heros are highly liked in the situation where you see their actions and do not play them out. It's actually why Anti-heros tend to never be the focus of a game as the protagonist even in triple A titles. The reason why in media of other types such as film, anime, books etc can pull of anti-heros is because we ourselves never face the ramifications of their actions. We can disconnect from the shitty things they are doing because we ourselves do not do them. However, we all have those thoughts of "What if I did kill this person?" etc... Seeing the anti-hero from a perspective that isn't direct, but an outsider looking in makes them very appealing.
They do and say the things one only wishes they could do. But, that's why being in direct control of them in games doesn't work for people as easily. Because in that scenario, you can't hide from the repercussions of your actions. It's easy to FEEL just how awful the things you are doing are. ((personally this was my issue with a game known as Watch_Dogs. They tried to protray a character who is.. actually an awful person a a good guy and the disconnect there really bothered me.)) You can feel just how terrible the actions you are taking are rather than see the fantasy, you see it, but you feel how awful it can make you feel, that's it isn't really what you wanted.
I think this in particular is what draws many people to characters like Titania. You see on the surface what she's doing and without thinking into it deeply, she's massively appealing. On the surface she seems strong, impenetrable, like someone who will do what others are not willing to do to protect others. However, the deeper one looks the more the facade crumbles.
Narratively, I think Titania is one of the better written characters because she's horribly flawed in what she does. I think as long as it's understood you REALLY shouldn't look up to her in any regard that like of her isn't a bad thing. It's when one tries to excuse the flaws when there's no reason you should excuse their actions. Titania from the things I know Is not a good person and is not a person you should want to be. She is someone who's fallen from grace, a cautionary tale more or less. She still has time to be redeemed I suppose, but... to me she a character I don't feel deserves to be redeemed. Narratively, I think her fate is sealed, as someone who tried to do the right things, but in the end, only temporarily solved the issues around her. Put off momentary pains, for grief that would only come back to strike 10 fold once it caught up to the lies. So, to me, she's vastly interesting. But, as a person I do not like her. For her role within the narrative I think she fits so well it almost is uncanny. I love her from that perspective but as a person... I really couldn't ever say she was a good one or a redeemable one.
I will note, I think the thing here is Titania is chasing the illusion of what strength is, the raw physical version. The very very narrow definition. That strength is only the ability to crush ones enemies. But, she fails to understand that there are other types of it as cliche as it sounds. The strength of empathy, compassion... and may other things. The strength in being honest and being just who you are. There's many other strengths in the world, and I think as a person she fails to see this. To her, the only way she can protect is to kill to destroy the threat to one's safety. It is this narrow definition that horribly and often leads to her hurting people more than truly helping them.
((that feel when I crawl out of my RP/CW hole to actually comment of something that is housed elsewhere on the forum for a change. Don't get used to this people. You'll be sorely disappointed. anyway, I probably won't notice replies to me directyl as that's the case, but,
With Love,
Hukuna Sensei~))