Jump to content

Refty365

Veterans
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    21

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Events

Reborn Development Blog

Rejuvenation Development Blog

Desolation Dev Blog

Everything posted by Refty365

  1. Refty365
    Drakyle, the coyote only attacks once, and once they do then their identity is made public—given the coyote has to make it to the end of the game to win, I doubt they’ll reveal their identity this early. Tbh, your explanation seems kind of sketchy imo (all you did was give a bad reason to not explain your role, and basically only say that you aren’t an outlaw; Anti at least gave us more info to work with, even putting himself at risk of being killed by the coyote).
  2. Refty365
    Also, how many outlaws are there—just three?
  3. Refty365
    So... who could’ve had a gun to shoot mega? Somebody that the gunsmith visited?
  4. Refty365
    Anti and Drakyle, can you each explain what you doing visiting Mega? The more information you give us, the more we can figure out what happened and help you.
  5. Refty365
    I'll play!
  6. Refty365
    Amber, how come you didn't roleclaim and share the fact that you investigated Mega and found him guilty? I knew the Judge was a crook
  7. Refty365
    Mega, are you the Judge? If so, you should defend yourself
  8. Refty365
    The Judge can reveal themselves (or be part of the court and have the court vindicate him/her)—right now it isn't worth taking the risk of letting the Judge kill anybody they want, so it's best to restrict them to only being able to vote.
  9. Refty365
    Ok great—now we've prevented one potential witch killing. After the night, we should have more information to go off of to figure out who to lynch next (because, unfortunately, I think we need to lynch a person a day until we can clear or condemn the Judge). Amine, why are you asking about the king? We (villagers) don't need to know who the King is—plus, outing the King would be a *huge* disadvantage.
  10. Refty365
    Anti, while I'm definitely not trusting Nagasi, I also know that we *need* to lynch somebody, and the only way we can do that is to lynch somebody (preferably someone who will die anyways, so we keep casualties low); it looks like our best bet right now is to lynch Shadow, and we could use the help to avoid letting the Judge go
  11. Refty365
    As I look now, shadowsusanoo is at zero posts (while cool girl is at two), so I'll change my vote to [Eliminate] Shadowsusanoo
  12. Refty365
    Anti, we were only trying to lynch somebody who would "die" due to inactivity anyways (not because we suspect cool girl, but because, like you said, we need to lynch somebody—we might as well minimize how many people die though). If Cool girl gets above the post limit, then I'll change my vote to somebody who is below it.
  13. Refty365
    Purple cicada, I agree—she was going to auto die anyways [Vote] Cool Girl
  14. Refty365
    Greninja: huh? Ok.... I got you fam lol I understand what you're saying Nagasi, but I also still hold a tiny bit of reservations... not enough to lynch you though. Again however, we do need to lynch somebody (see my last several posts for my reasoning). If Greninja has some evidence that proves my innocence (and I am innocent, which makes me trust him more now tbh), then maybe it shouldn't be me, but someone that could be a witch (or somebody that hasn't met post requirements). What do you guys think? Again, if you don't trust me, I am ok if you decide to lynch me.
  15. Refty365
    I think that we either lynch Nagasi or myself—I have strong suspicions about the Judge, and I would rather that they are refused the opportunity to randomly kill a potentially very valuable player. It's also kind of sketchy that Nagasi hasn't said anything in their defense (but they could just be busy doing something else atm). I think the Gravedigger should stay hidden for now, because the only info that would be really illuminating is if Alistair was a witch (which would basically clear the Judge of suspicion), but any other information would be inconclusive—thus, it wouldn't be worth it for the gravedigger to reveal their self. But in regards to Nagasi's choice possibly influencing the judge: Nagasi was acting pretty sketchy, so I really doubt that the Judge decided to treat Nagasi's unqualified opinion as good enough reason to lynch Alistair (not impossible, but still improbable imo). That still leaves the Judge as suspicious, as far as I'm concerned. I think, as of now, the best course of action is to lynch Nagasi (or me, if you disagree with me or suspect me) to prevent the Judge from having the option to kill. I do think, however, that if Nagasi (or somebody else) were to add information that changed/clarified things, that our course of action should/could change. What do you guys think?
  16. Refty365
    What do you say in your defense Nagisa? Can you point out what specifically was suspicious (so that Nagisa can defend their self with more clarity) Lykos?
  17. Refty365
    If we can't agree on lynching someone that is suspect, just vote to lynch me—my role isn't all that helpful, and I can be helpful as an angel. I'd rather have someone not helpful (me) die, than let the judge potentially lynch someone important.
  18. Refty365
    Yeah. I get your point that quietness/loudness doesn't necessarily condemn someone as being a witch, but we've got to work with what we've got, right? Idk, this is my first time playing (as I've already mentioned) so I don't know exactly what good strategies are lol. But hey, I've got to go, just to let you know (so dropping out of the conversation doesn't seem super questionable lol)
  19. Refty365
    And I agree, Roswell and Alistair were definitely going to be targets just based off of their experience (plus their strategizing only made them stick out more, unfortunately)
  20. Refty365
    Wait, Nagisa did you just claim to be the Judge?
  21. Refty365
    Well if Roswell is experienced and implied that he had a good role, then it would be kind of obvious why the Coven would want to kill him. I'm not sure we can figure out why Alistair was lynched without somebody using their role's action to somehow determine if the Judge was a witch, or if the Judge just came out and told us. But I guess the Judge saw what Alistair said and acted based off of that, but Alistair talked almost exactly like Roswell talked—if Alistair was a witch, it would be quite the coincidence (imo) if Roswell was working from a different starting point (i.e. Allegiance). I'm still kind of suspecting the Judge to be a Coven member tbh—it offers the most explanation for what happened. I don't know though, the Judge also could have just been somebody who is more trigger-happy (but then that would either be characteristic of somebody who plays these games regularly, or somebody who is inexperienced).
  22. Refty365
    Ok, another possibly dumb theory—what if the people who are barely posting (Greninja, Paul, and Amine to name a few) don't feel much of a compulsion to post here and play because they're talking to each other (or just others) in the Coven? It seems kind of weird to me that they're not adding much.... seems like what a witch would do (try and keep a low profile and fly under the radar) Granted, they could just be busy or trying to keep a low profile because that's just a smart move in general, but whoever the witches are will definitely be putting more effort into concealment.
  23. Refty365
    And yeah, that makes sense.
  24. Refty365
    Wait lol, what's the running joke?
  25. Refty365
    This might sound kind of dumb, but what if the Judge is one of the witches (it is possible for any non holy/royalty role to be a witch)? Alistair and Roswell had a lot in common—what if the motivation for each killing was the same? Also, why would the Judge kill someone day 1? Either they're new/inexperienced/suspecting, or they're a witch.
×
×
  • Create New...