Another suicide?!? (WARNING might contain spoliers)

[The Swordsman]

So the weather finally became sunny so I was able to progress some more and everything was going smoothly until I went to get the Surf TM. After reading Titania's diary you're given a dialogue tree which all the paths ends with Amaria trying to commit suicide and Titania jumping after her in an attempt to try to save her life and while I doubt the first question really matters (Did you read my diary?) the second (keep quiet or not) is giving me a headache over which option is the right thing to do. On one hand if Amaria survives and I told her the truth, that honesty might let me convince her not to kill herself if she tries again. On the other hand if I kept quiet and she does kill herself no matter what you do I and hopefully Titania won't blame myself for her death once Ep. 15 comes around or if she survives Titania's view of me won't be too negative.(hopefully will be able to team up against Team Meteor) So what should I do? Because I really really don't want Amaria to die.

[Fumble]

I vote no, since that makes you seem nicer to Tania, but spoilers down below.

Amaria jumps off the waterfall no matter what. However... according to the E15 teaser, two screens in Shade's Gym was fake. Meaning Amaria won't be dead. Besides, in the real Reborn League, there was no other Water Gym Leader, so there's nobody to replace her if she does die in game. What happened to her in real life, well, you might be able to figure this one out by researching.)

[CURIE]

Amaria lives either way, but this brings up a question I've been meaning to ask: Which path is the one we have to take for the "extra ending"? Do either of them even matter? Does one matter and not the other?

[Foamy]

Has this "extra ending" even been confirmed? I've only seen a ton of people speculate about it.

[Meruem]

yes. destroy her life.

[AuthorReborn]

Has this "extra ending" even been confirmed? I've only seen a ton of people speculate about it.

I don't remember where exactly, but I remember Ame saying something along the lines of having two endings: one that's the basic ending and another that you can only achieve through doing absolutely everything exactly right. So yeah. That's a thing.

[Vinny]

I don't remember where exactly, but I remember Ame saying something along the lines of having two endings: one that's the basic ending and another that you can only achieve through doing absolutely everything exactly right. So yeah. That's a thing.

Ame went full on Katawa Shoujo mode, didn't she?

Welp...

Bad ending, Neutral ending and Good ending expected.

EDIT: Btw, to stay on topic... hmm, No, don't tell her the truth. At least, until I see the result of my actions in episode 15, there's no way I can determine whether is better to say the truth or not. Just go with No to avoid an Aegislash to the chest.

Edited May 16, 2015 by Vinny

[JustinVentus]

Ame went full on Katawa Shoujo mode, didn't she?

Welp...

Bad ending, Neutral ending and Good ending expected.

EDIT: Btw, to stay on topic... hmm, No, don't tell her the truth. At least, until I see the result of my actions in episode 15, there's no way I can determine whether is better to say the truth or not. Just go with No to avoid an Aegislash to the chest.

I agree

[Gaunt]

Bad ending, Neutral ending and Good ending expected.

[/s]

Blue, red and green?

[Kithros]

In regards to the 'extra ending' it's entirely possible people completely misinterpretted what was being said - as I recall it said something along the lines of 'for people who did pretty much everything' or something to that effect. That might not even mean the choices you make during the story - it's entirely possible that's just talking about all of the sidequests in which case it might have an ending showing what happens to some of the minor characters (like Simon for instance).

[NameNotFound]

I vote for no. I'm not sure if telling her the truth is the right thing to do since we read something we shouldn't have .-.

Edited May 16, 2015 by NameNotFound

[CURIE]

In regards to the 'extra ending' it's entirely possible people completely misinterpretted what was being said - as I recall it said something along the lines of 'for people who did pretty much everything' or something to that effect. That might not even mean the choices you make during the story - it's entirely possible that's just talking about all of the sidequests in which case it might have an ending showing what happens to some of the minor characters (like Simon for instance).

Nope, I asked for clarification myself and she gave it. It's all about which storylines you pick, hence why I want to know which one to pick here.

[Foamy]

In all honesty, it's a lose-lose situation. You hide the truth from her in order to effectively save her life, but you hurt her feelings and damage her trust in doing so.
On the other hand, if you DO tell her the truth, you're basically saying "Hey, your girlfriend doesn't love you and she never did," which not only is a dickish thing to say, but it'll also send her into a suicidal state of manic depression.
(Plus, you piss off Titania. That's never a good idea.)

Edited May 21, 2015 by Foamy

[PsychoticPudu]

Ame kinda said "there's one ending and another one that goes a liiitle further if you got everything". "Everything" may be anything. It may be an alternate ending, a bonus if you complete the dex, etc. She wouldn't give too many details in something like that.

[Elios]

Personally, I don´t want Amaria do die. However, if she is gonna commit suicide, I hope that she give us her badge before die. xD

Edited May 22, 2015 by Elios

[Helia]

This is what I think is going on:

Amaria seems to have been depressed for quite a while now, it was only a matter of time before she would snap. Titania just leaving her diary out and about with all the information while Amaria could come home any time soon isn't a bright idea on her part.

It would seem Titania was the one that kept her juuuust off the edge all this time.

Also, it seems to me that Titania and Ameria starting dating together was the start of Florinia's career as Flobot.

I think Flo and Titania were secretly dating back while they were attending the Onyx ward School. Ameria's depression was already shining through, and Titania, being a great friend, spent a lot of time with Ameria to make her feel better, slowly neglecting Florinia's needs. Ameria, not fully aware of Florinia and Titania dating, thought that Titania's attention meant she really loved her, making her happy and less depressed. Titania was not able to pull out of that relationship, trying to avoid the shit that would inevitably happen, as witnessed by the player.

Honestly Ameria is so deluded by her depression that she couldn't see the truth, ripping apart two people's lives so she could feel better.

Either way Titania is the loser in this story.

[The Swordsman]

Poll is now closed and the majority has voted for me to tell her the truth. Thank you to everyone who voted and replied to this topic!

Ame went full on Katawa Shoujo mode, didn't she?

Welp...

Bad ending, Neutral ending and Good ending expected.

EDIT: Btw, to stay on topic... hmm, No, don't tell her the truth. At least, until I see the result of my actions in episode 15, there's no way I can determine whether is better to say the truth or not. Just go with No to avoid an Aegislash to the chest.

When you are able can you PM me on what happens please?