Jump to content

Reborn Book Review Thread


mde2001

Recommended Posts

REMINDER: When submitting reviews please state which section they go into. This just makes my life a lot easier!

Reading is an activity that I've loved my whole life, and despite the fact that lots of people seem not to like books that much, I'm sure there are plenty of other people who have this in common with me. However, the age old struggle for readers is running out of books to read. Rather than making a thread where people post what they enjoy and get suggestions, I've decided to make a thread dedicated to reviews of books, sorted into categories based on what they're about.

So if there is a book you've loved make a post here (I'll give specifications on how reviews should be submitted to help me keep the OP up to date). Then if you ever need inspiration for what to read next, look in the section dedicated to what you feel like reading and see if any reviews there interest you. Hopefully this will let us all share our reading preferences with the other avid readers and continue to enjoy doing what we love!

I'm planning on having this thread run a little bit like the monotype threads where people write up reviews that get edited into the OP. So given this is going to be a thread with lots of books in it, reviews can't be too lengthy, around 200 words max if possible. If these could include a brief outline of the plot, what you thought the books strengths are, and why people should read it (also any other information you want- I don't want to be too controlling on this). I'm not going to incorporate rankings, as this thread is really only meant for books you enjoyed a lot, and I always feel like assigning a number to how good a book is oversimplifies things massively. If books do contain more mature themes that might be confronting, giving a bit of warning about this is appreciated. If books that are super sexually explicit (e.g. stuff like Fifty Shades of Grey) weren't written up that'd be great- obviously that isn't to say books with sex in them aren't allowed- just use your judgement and you should be fine.

If you want to include key details of the plot that don't occur relatively early in the books using spoiler tags would be appreciated!

The only other thing that should be included (other than author and title) is which of the categories below it fits into. If you feel like I should add a category feel free to let me know as well! I want this thread to be a community run thing, so if you feel like there is a way to improve it let me know! If a book fits more than one category then just chose one of them. I'm going to put who wrote each review, so if you're more interested in the book I'd encourage you to engage in discussion about it with them!

So here are the reviews:

Classics:

  Reveal hidden contents

Fantasy:

  Reveal hidden contents

Science-Fiction:

  Reveal hidden contents

Based on True Stories:

  Reveal hidden contents

Historical Fiction:

  Reveal hidden contents

Romance:

  Reveal hidden contents

Mystery:

  Reveal hidden contents

Horror:

  Reveal hidden contents

Emotional/ Character:

  Reveal hidden contents

Comedy:

  Reveal hidden contents

Religion/ Mythology:

  Reveal hidden contents

Fact/ Non Fiction

  Reveal hidden contents

Biography

  Reveal hidden contents

Action:

  Reveal hidden contents

Supernatural

  Reveal hidden contents

Adventure

  Reveal hidden contents

Graphic Novels:

  Reveal hidden contents

I've started it off with a few books, but will add more later and encourage everyone to add their ideas. I'm not doing any sort of quality judgement on whether I believe the book is good, or the review is good. This thread isn't mine, I'm simply going to be updating the post to reflect everyone's suggestions. I can't wait to hear what you guys have read and want on here!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why, this is wonderful! I might be a sesquipedalian, but for once I can't find the words to express how happy I am that a library of sorts is being made here! I'm certain that this will make the community as a whole a lot more fleshed out, with myriads of branches available in literature.

Michael, you have my full support, and I would definitely love to contribute in my capacity to this thread!

For a start, though, why not add a section for fact? Subdivided into categories for History, Geography, Natural Philosophy, Economics or the Sciences?

Granted, this is a lot more serious that novellas and even classics, but there's a wealth of academic and philosophical treatises out there that should not be missed by those inclined to peruse them. I'll come up with reviews and suggestions shortly!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

*is actually so happy he makes another post for the hell of it. I don't even care if you haul me over the coals for this*

But truly, I do think I can contribute to this thread; I love talking about books! I also suppose there ought be a guideline about enclosing important bits, especially of fiction, in spoiler tags, so that the impecunious reader does not have his plot spoiled.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

urghha this is gunna be one of those threads i'll have to grammar in.

i picked off the first books i found on my bookshelf, welp, autobiographies mostly, but here we go

The Art of War (孫子兵法), by Sun Tzu

The book deals in war strategies; it's thin, simple and straight to the point and every copy I've gotten my hands on has a foreword by someone that sounds like they should be in jail. Almost of none of the content sounds like it would applicable in real life to someone not a soldier (when you plunder villages, don't violate the women, guys). And yet, it's a compelling book, because of it's importance. It has helped nations won wars. It's helped us to shape modern warfare. China would not be the same country without the existence of these barely 100 pages. It's the Citizen Kane of warfare, and that's why you should read it.

Autobiography - Morrissey

Steven Patrick Morrissey is a self-righteous asshole. But he makes good music, good lyrics, even if Johnny Marr should be the real hero of the Smiths, Morrissey has earned his stardom the hard way, and this is a story about how.

Unfortunately, his magnificent lyrics doesn't translate to book form. I lose sight of the story from his convoluted metaphors about how the streets look, how evil his teachers were; this book is written with a pen in one hand, and a book with unnecessary synonyms in the other. Opening a page on random, the first new sentence is "The band is listed as the Nosebleeds, and I am lumbered with this miscued name in private sufferance forevermore." If Tolkien had a description overdose problem, Morrissey has 99 of them.

All that being said, it's probably the best autobiography I've ever read, because it's so unmistakable him. There's a unmistakable beauty in his word mangling, and it's a very very honest story of how this man came to be as he is today. The understated humor, the sometimes-poetic portraits of everyone around him, the middle-wage life – I wish I was in this book, if only to hear how he'd describe me.

i picked out four more that's on my bedside table now, i'll edit them in after i brought some caffeine

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looks like this thread is going to make my ever growing list of books to read go out of bonds.

I love the idea and I'll try to add some reviews of things I've read whenever I find something I really want to share.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Alright, I'm bored and it's 3 AM so i'll type up a review for ya:

A Whole New World; A Twisted Tale, By Liz Braswell

  Reveal hidden contents



(Edited for gRAMM3R!!!1)

Edited by Pocky
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm gonna start with a good ol' classic:

  Reveal hidden contents

This should go into Science Fiction, though I guess it is old enough to be considered a classic.

I'll write more reviews when I have the time. ; )

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here it goes, one of my favorites ever.

A song of ice and fire by George R. R. Martin

A song of ice and fire is a series of five books (and other two not written yet) which you probably know for the TV series Game of thrones, that supposed an inflexion point in the way I understand literature.
There are two main differences with the rest of fantastic novels: In AGOT there are no protagonists, and there’s no “good” and “evil”. Each chapter of the books is told from the perspective of a character, so you get to know the viewpoints of all of the parts in the conflict. This way, there’s no “good” and “evil” as I mentioned before, but different sides with their own interests and ideas. Besides, there’s not a central character who you know that will survive until the end of the story. Anyone can die at any moment, no matter the importance it has had up to that point.
For the ones sensitive about these topics, there are several sexually explicit and violent scenes throughout the five books. It’s not as frequent as in the TV series, where this was magnified to the absurd because boobs are the best way to sell your product nowadays, but still there are some.
In general, the books tell a great story with well built characters and a very rich world. They are also a nice conversation topic if you have friends who have read them, as there are still two books that haven’t been written and there’s lots to speculate about. Finally, it provides this change to the way we have always written fantasy that I consider that needs to be mentioned.

It should go into fantasy I guess.

Edited by Lugruf
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1984 is like, my favorite book ♥ or at least one of them. Such great taste, much wow. Agree that it should be under sci-fi; it's like, the sci-fi book.

Making a new post instead 'cause more people posted. I think Art of War should be under non-fiction - philosophy.

And here's to Non-fiction, science.

How to Create a Mind by Ray Kurzweil.

'Ray Kurzweil is the best person I know at predicting the future of artificial intelligence', says Bill Gates. This book goes through how our brains work, and how to translate that into artificial intelligence. Even if it was written in 2012, it's more relevant than ever now that two artificial intelligence robots have said they wanted to destroy humanity in less than a week. It doesn't dumb anything down; there's algorithms over how to program speech, how our morals set in, and how to fake fear. It explains how love, creativity and patterns of the neocortex. We're all going to live long enough to live with artificial intelligence as an essential part of our lives - we should know how it will work.

i rewrote the morrissey one, sorry, but i was falling asleep during draft one

Autobiography - Morrissey
Steven Patrick Morrissey is a self-righteous asshole. But he's a good musician, superb lyricist, and he has earned his stardom the hard way – this book details what shaped him.
Unfortunately, Morrissey's magnificent lyrics doesn't always translate to a longer format. I sometimes lose sight of the story from his convoluted metaphors about how the streets look, his teachers, and how they'll die alone and unloved; this book is written with a pen in one hand, and a book with flimsy synonyms in the other. Opening a page on random, the first new sentence is "The band is listed as the Nosebleeds, and I am lumbered with this miscued name in private sufferance forevermore." If Tolkien had a description overdose problem, Morrissey has 99 of them.
All that being said, it's probably the best autobiography I've ever read, because it's so unmistakable him. There's a distinct beauty in his word mangling, and it's a very very honest story of how this man came to be as he is today. The understated humor, the sometimes-poetic portraits of everyone around him, the middle-wage life – I wish I was in this book, if only to hear how he'd describe me. And after a while it even gets interesting; heavens knows he's been miserable.
And here's some Sci-fi; along with George Orwell and Anthony Burgess, Philip has really helped with shaping me into a cynical asshole.
Do Androids Dream of Electrical Sheep - Philip K. Dick
What defines "life"?
On a desolate earth, Rick Deckard hunts down and kills rogue artificial intelligence robots, so humanoid that they're almost impossible to distinguish from actual humans. Rick isn't in it to bring money to his bored wife, nor for the thrill of it, no, Rick is saving up for the ultimate status symbol – a real life animal. It follows him as he starts to question the difference between flesh and electrical wires, when live starts mattering - and what things we can't fake. It's an interesting dissection of humanity, a sci-fi classic and a thought-provoking portrait of a man. Philip K. Dick is perhaps the most influential sci-fi writer of all time; with brilliant ideas and splendid execution, he doesn't waste words, doesn't pull any punches and doesn't let you put down anything he's written.
And finally, another Autobiography. I guess?
Please Kill Me by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain
It's a rough assemble of interviews and magazine cut outs; it's a narrative as honest as it is unreliable, it's a confession of pedophilia, power struggle, drug abuse and violence that made it down as one of our music culture's defining milestones. It's the story of punk, and it's exactly as it should be told. Iggy Pop, David Bowie, Sid Vicious, Lou Reed and Andy Warholt all feature in this clusterfuck of horribly broken people that somehow all re-defined music. Perhaps because it's all real-life, it's one of the most honest portraits of humanity I ever had the pleasure to come over; they describe addiction, back-stabbing and loss with a candor that only comes from having been there. It's remarkable easy to read too; I absolutely swallowed it, and yet there's paragraphs that I actually had to bookmark because they hit me so hard.
However, if you have absolutely no interest in punk, it pains me to say that this probably not the book for you; it's a high-speed train crash that throw out names like snow cannons compress water.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

For a start, I'd recommend some humour, of the good old 1930s kind.

I'm not sure if many here are familiar with the works of P.G.Wodehouse? The creator of Jeeves and Wooster, Blandings Castle, Psmith, Ukridge and Mr.Mulliner among others, his series of works paint a jolly, light-hearted picture of English society at the time, particularly English aristocracy. In a way, Wodehouse tends to take a preconception and turn it upside down and inside out, in his own unique style.

The most iconic of his works is the Jeeves and Wooster series, which revolve around the tribulations of Bertram (Bertie) Wooster, a sporting but simple-minded young aristocrat, and his valet Jeeves, who usually uses his intelligence and tact to save Bertie and his pals from many a funny or awkward social situation, usually involving one of Bertie's tyrannical aunts or a friend's love affair.

While a simple Google search will show the reader the entire collection, my personal favourites of the lot, where Wodehouse shines at his brightest, are these:

  Reveal hidden contents

I admit that, especially to a new reader who doesn't know the context, this summary or review of mine mayn't capture the humour in its fullest, but I assure you of Wodehouse's way of enthralling the reader, carrying them off into a wonderful world where nothing is more serious than a stolen umbrella and several people getting engaged to the wrong people before everything going right in the end. He remains, in my view, the best chronicler of a certain kind of Englishness, with wit that none has been able to reproduce.

Edited by Viridescent
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Support Squad

You might need more genres.

Worm- Web serial by J.C McCrae. It can go in action, sci-fi and maybe a little bit of horror is in there too.

For those not familiar with web serials, the first thing you should know is that Web serials tend to be incredibly long. Worm is no exception. To quote the home page that gives a quick summary of the book. "It totals roughly 1,680,000 words; roughly 26 typical novels in length (or 10-11 very thick novels)." So if you give it a try, be prepared to stick through a lot.

So, let me now summarise the serial. It is about an introverted young woman named Taylor who has the capability to control bugs in this superhero filled world. The story begins with her first attempt to take down a bona fide badass of a villain, the notorious leader of a local gang, because she aspires to be a hero. Shit goes down, she proves how bugs can be scary and the circumstances evolve. The story follows Taylors induction and adaptation to the Superpower community in the main setting of Brockton Bay. McCrae uses Taylors perspective to explore morality in this world and explore what a society would be like in such a world. If that doesn't interest you, bear in mind, Taylor does not start off on the good guys side.

Now, for what makes this serial shine. Power scaling and action. The writer is fantastic at choreographing action scenes and the unique set of powers in the very, very large cast is used very creatively. In specific Taylor's capability to control bugs, something that seems insignificant, is proved to be something incredibly versatile and downright scary. A character who has very good intuition as a superpower is actually one of the most feared characters in the series.

Then there's the threats. The characters and monsters that are literal walking disasters. The Endbringer battles are some of the most harrowing scenes I've read. If you think Game of Thrones is liberal with character death, then Worm takes it up a notch because no one is safe in these fights. In the first Endbringer battle in the series, it has been said that McCrae simply rolled dice to determine if a character survived.

One final note about the finale. No spoilers, don'tchu worry child. but I like to think a finale is one of the bigest selling points of a story so it needs to be discussed. The finale is, well, it's built up for a long, long time. It takes a while to get there and it drags as it approaches. However, the final arc of the series, holee shit, the final arc is every bit as climactic as you could want. It's orchestrated perfectly, every faction plays it's role and the Big Bad is no joke. The epilogue alone leaves you with a little sigh of satisfaction.

So, go read it, Worm is good.

Next, from the same Author, the second Webserial to their name, Pact. This is a Horror/Action story without any doubt.

This story is quite long but not to the extent of Worm, much smaller. In case you wanted something a little less. This story follows Blake Thorburn, Blake used to be a part of a very unhappy family constantly vying for the grandmothers favour so they can inherit the Thorburn estate. However, the Thorburn estate and the surrounding area is not normal by any means and Blake finds himself plunged into a goddamn terrifying, if ordered, world of every monster under the bed.

The high points of Pact aren't as evident for me as they may be for others but I can appreciate them. For one, McCrae is god damn fantastic at writing horrific creatures of the beyond. Some of these things are just shy of being Eldritch abominations. When McCrae wants to be terrifying, they are fucking scary.

Another pro of the series was touched on in my revew of Worm. McCrae is very good at Choreographing action scenes and whilst action isn't quite as prevalent, this choreography actually transfers very well into interactions. Due to the nature of monsters, these interactions are as close to verbal sparring as you can get so this skill is used very well.

There is a glaring Con of the series and that is just, it's depressing as all hell at times. Naturally it's not meant to be bright and happy but the things that happen to each of the characters is pretty devastating. The shit Blake has to wade through is insane and barring a grand total of two characters there's practically no one else going through it with him. Along side him yes but not with him. The plus side of this is that there are some huge crowning moments of badass.

The finale for Pact. McCrae does some pretty good finales in my eyes. The consequences may not be the best but dammit all if it wasn't awesome. You know one of those crowning moments of badass? All I'm going to say is: Defenestration.

So there's two of my reviews and I've got many, many more to go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wasn't going to post this initially due to the fact that the book is in Spanish and not translated. However, some people encouraged me to do so and well, here I go.

9788483659168.jpg9788483657935.jpg

La chica de Los Planetas - Holden Centeno

(The author's nickname, literally Holden Rye, is a reference to the Catcher in the rye's Holden Caulfield.)

La chica de Los Planetas is a beautiful and heartbreaking love story where the author narrates his relationship with a girl. The girl is refered to as chica de Los Planetas (girl of the planets) or other nicknames to keep her anonymous.
So, what's special about this book? Why should I read this instead of any other of the dull love stories that flood our book stores nowadays? Well, the book is written in first person, in a Catcher of the rye-ish style that catches the reader and makes him feel very close to the protagonist. The reader lives every up and down in their relationship, from the falling in love and the first overly sweet weeks when everything's happiness to the doubts and arguements, to every time they break up and come back.
It's important too the fact that the story really happened, so the character's are round and act like humans. One of the main problems I find with certain stories is that they're not believable because of how the characters act and talk, because dialogue looks too forced instead of a real conversation you could have with a real person. Here, it doesn't happen at all.

Throughout the story the protagonist will also mention lots of books and music bands, so the book is also a good chance to disscover some music you might have not heard and books you haven't read.
In general, if you want a beautiful love story that can catch you and make you believe that there's hope and love exists, read this book. Then, if you want to cry with the hard moments, estrangement and the end of a beautiful relationship, you can read the second part.

Edited by Lugruf
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay all books have been edited in.

Dobby- if you want any genres added just let me know and I'll add them. I just did all the ones I could think off from the top of my head and most likely missed some good ones. So I'm happy to put in whatever.

Huk- In terms of books going in more than one section, rather than putting the review in twice- I've put a tag of where you can find the review within the sections (e.g. If you look in classics you'll see 1984- Review in Science Fiction). This will just save space and allow more books.

Viri- I wasn't 100% sure what you wanted included in the reviews, so if you could check I've done what you wanted with the Jeeves and Wooster books is what you want, that'd be great. I put them under comedy and put in a reference of where they are in classics.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Support Squad

First one of the top of my head is supernatural. That in itself will cover a lot of bases. For example, The Dresden Files. It fits into fantasy, action, mystery and several others but I'm sure anyone else who has read the series will agree with me that supernatural is the most fitting.

And I will be talking about the D files at some point. Or Fanboying, either or.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Last time I recommended 1930-40s Comedy. Now I recommended 1940s fact, and dead serious at that.

I'm sure that most history books worldwide would mention the Normandy Landings of 1944. I believe it's important for as many people to learn world history as possible, the more and deeper the better, and this is a very significant part of it.

Max Hastings's definitive book, 'Overlord', details how on June 6, 1944, American and British troops staged the greatest amphibious landing in history to begin Operation Overlord, the battle to liberate Europe from the scourge of the Third Reich. With gut-wrenching realism and immediacy, Hastings reveals the terrible human cost that this battle exacted, with many British and American infantry units suffering near 100 percent casualties during the course of that awful summer.

Far from a gauzy romanticized remembrance, Hastings details a grueling ten week battle to overpower the superbly trained, geographically entrenched German Wehrmacht. This book is acclaimed as the definitive chronicle of D-Day and the Battle of Normandy.

Edited by Viridescent
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Added both the category for supernatural and Overlord for you Viri. By the sounds of your review, I think it is fiction- so I put the book under historical fiction. If this isn't where you want it I can move it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mmm? No one else contributed anything since my last post, so don't hand out warning points for a double post, OK? OK.

This time, I recommend Frederick Forsyth's iconic 'The Day of the Jackal' as my suggestion. Forsyth is a master of the 'thriller' and his entire series ought to be a staple in any library which contains an Action or Thriller section.

Review: The Day of the Jackal (set in 1963) is the gripping story of the struggle to catch a remorseless assassin, hired by the OAS to kill Charles de Gaulle, the then President of France, before it is too late. This is the book that skyrocketed Forsyth's name; it's simply in a class by itself.

Of course, one reading this must bear in mind that this classic Thriller is set in the 1960s. Had the same story been written today, the plot would've failed in ten minutes with today's technology and resources.

Those interested in more Forsyth should read The Avenger and it's sequel, The Cobra. This is set in 2010, so it Incorporates today's world much better, but they're all equally excellent as a read.

Edited by Viridescent
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I really don't want this thread to die, so here's more reviews!

My most recent book:

  Reveal hidden contents

This should go into Adventure - Classic.

And as the wise DJ Khaled says:

Another one.

  Reveal hidden contents

I believe this should go into Mystery.

More reviews when I feel like it. >:3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...