Season 1 Onyx Arcade Mafia Awards Voting Thread

[Daniel Blackworth]

Season 1 Onyx Arcade Mafia Awards

Alola! I am proud to welcome you to the Season 1 Onyx Arcade Mafia Awards Voting Thread. In these past six months, Mafia games have become a part of the great gambling subforum of Reborn, the Onyx Arcade. Some players have come and gone while others have stayed to play while some have also become interested in hosting Mafia games. Before we end the first season of Mafia games, we recognize the efforts of hosts and the skills and talents of players through having different and varied Awards which acknowledge them. 

Rules for Voting:

 

(1) All 14 games, beginning with Stranded: A Mafia Game until Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade Mafia, are eligible for voting in terms of the games themselves and their respective hosts and players.

(2) Voters must have played at least one game in Season 1 to be eligible for voting.

(3) Voters must copy the voting sheet and indicate their votes on the respective categories for their votes to count. They may fill in selected categories or place a vote on all categories. Only one vote will be acknowledged per Award.

(4) Voters may not vote for themselves, nor are they allowed to vote for a team which they were a member of or a game they hosted.

(5) All voting will be done in the thread. Voters may change or edit their votes in the duration of the voting session, but they must notify me regarding changes.

(6) Voters may or may not explain the reason for their votes.

(7) The Voting Session will end on December 7, 2017. If you wish to vote, please do so before the aforementioned date.

Eligible Games:

 

(1) Stranded: A Mafia Game [MAFIA] - Myrmidon Divergent 

(2) Magic and Curses! Another Mafia Game [TOWN] - Myrmidon Divergent

(3) Reborn Girls "Fight for Love" Mafia [TOWN] - Myrmidon Divergent

(4) Criminal Showdown Mafia [TP-SURVIVOR] - Sailboat

(5) Mafia Mania: Investigations [TOWN] - Myrmidon Divergent

(6) Dark Ages Mafia [MAFIA] - Sailboat

(7) Pokemon: Choose your Own Character Mafia [TP-CULT] - Myrmidon Divergent

(8) Mafia: Trouble in Fire Emblem [MAFIA] - Jace Stormkirk

(9) WitchHunt! [MAFIA] - Myrmidon Divergent

(10) Wild West Showdown Mafia [TP-COYOTE] -  Myrmidon Divergent

(11) Mafia: A Star Wars Story [MAFIA] - Alistair

(12) Mafia: Halloween Edition [TOWN] - Lord Drakyle

(13) Hospital Mafia [TOWN] -  Anti_Hero

(14) Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade Mafia [TOWN] - Myrmidon Divergent

* Words in brackets represent the factional/individual winners of respective games.

Award Descriptions:

 

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - An award given to the most dedicated and connected town group coordination in a specific game.
★ Best Mafia Coordination - An award given to the most united and deceitful mafia group coordination in a specific game.
★ Best Third Party Coordination - An award given to the most successful third party group coordination in a specific game.

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - An award given to the most trustworthy and strategic town performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Best Mafia Performance - An award given to the most deceitful and convincing mafia performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Best Third Party Performance - An award given to the most masterful third party performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Easiest Player to read - An award given to the player whom you can read like an open book or easily associate with an alignment.
★ Hardest Player to read - An award given to the player who is difficult to understand in terms of alignment and motives.
★ Always Town Award - An award given to the player whom you can almost always associate with town.
★ Always Mafia Award - An award given to the player whom you can almost always count on to be mafia.
★ Most Tactical Player - An award given to the most strategic player and the best when it comes to reading other players.
★ Most Interesting Player - An award given to the most exciting player or the player who manages to shake things up always.
★ Most Unfortunate Player - An award given to the unluckiest player or one who gets the most unfortunate circumstances.

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up - An award given to the game with the most interesting role combinations and mechanics.
★ Most Organized Game - An award given to the most well-organized game in terms of aspects such as deadlines, announcements, night action interaction, and other related notions.
★ Favorite Game - An award given to your personal favorite game.
★ Most Creative Host - An award given to the host who comes up with the most creative mechanics and concepts for their games.
★ Most Interesting Host - An award given to the host who produces the best narratives and storylines.
★ The Judge Host - An award given to the most impartial and fair host in terms of relating to players and factions. 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - An award given to the person who possesses all good qualities of a friend.
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining -  An award given to the person whom you can always count on to be interesting and can always come up with fun ideas.
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Award - An award given to the most commited person or the most wholesome person all around.

Voting Sheet:

 

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination
★ Best Third Party Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read
★ Hardest Player to read
★ Always Town Award
★ Always Mafia Award
★ Most Tactical Player
★ Most Interesting Player
★ Most Unfortunate Player

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up
★ Most Organized Game
★ Favorite Game
★ Most Creative Host
★ Most Interesting Host
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia

I thank the Reborn Mafia Community for their insights regarding possible Awards and for their active participation and positive feedback!

Edited November 30, 2017 by Myrmidon Divergent

[Chickens]

No award for the most death? I have only played in 1 game so i cant say much

 

Player Awards:

Team Category 

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination
★ Best Third Party Coordination 

Individual Category 

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read
★ Hardest Player to read
★ Always Town Award
★ Always Mafia Award
★ Most Tactical Player
★ Most Interesting Player      VENUS
★ Most Unfortunate Player    ALISTAIR

Host and Mafia Game Awards: 

★ Most Interesting Set-up      CHRONICLES OF THE ONYX ARCADE MAFIA
★ Most Organized Game
★ Favorite Game
★ Most Creative Host
★ Most Interesting Host
★ The Judge Host 

Reborn Mafia Awards: 

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia      MYRMIDON DIVERGENT

[Daniel Blackworth]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - Mafia Mania: Investigations Town Group
★ Best Mafia Coordination - WitchHunt! Mafia Group
★ Best Third Party Coordination - Pokemon: Choose your Own Character Mafia Cult Group

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - Jace Stormkirk from Mafia Mania: Investigations
★ Best Mafia Performance - Purplecicada from WitchHunt!
★ Best Third Party Performance - LykosHand from Pokemon Mafia
★ Easiest Player to read - LykosHand
★ Hardest Player to read - EndearingCharacterTrait
★ Always Town Award - Roswell
★ Always Mafia Award - Megagun
★ Most Tactical Player - Megagun
★ Most Interesting Player - Venus
★ Most Unfortunate Player - Venus

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up - Dark Ages Mafia
★ Most Organized Game - Star Wars Mafia
★ Favorite Game - Dark Ages Mafia
★ Most Creative Host - Sailboat
★ Most Interesting Host - (Abstain)
★ The Judge Host -  Alistair

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - Anti_Hero
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining - Purplecicada
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia - Alistair

Edited November 30, 2017 by Myrmidon Divergent

[sailboat]

Spoiler

Player Awards:

Team Category 

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination
★ Best Third Party Coordination 

Individual Category 

★ Best Town Performance -Megagun Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Best Mafia Performance -Megagun  Dark Ages
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read -Alistair
★ Hardest Player to read -Hycrox
★ Always Town Award -S.Paul
★ Always Mafia Award -Anti_Hero
★ Most Tactical Player -Jace Stormkirk
★ Most Interesting Player -cant vote too many to mention!
★ Most Unfortunate Player  -cant vote! At least 5 peeps i think are quite unfortunate in certain circumstances and  that is not counting eliminate alistair d1/n1!

Host and Mafia Game Awards: 

★ Most Interesting Set-up -Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Most Organized Game
★ Favorite Game -Magic and Curses!
★ Most Creative Host
★ Most Interesting Host -Myrmidon Divergent
★ The Judge Host 

Reborn Mafia Awards: 

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining 
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia -Myrmidon Divergent

 

Edited November 30, 2017 by sailboat

[Daniel Blackworth]

For Best Town Performance, Best Mafia Performance, and Best Third Party Performance, please mention the specific game they had the best performance in.

 

@sailboat @Hooligan

 

Also, for Best Town Coordination, Best Mafia Coordination, and Best Third Party Performance, you have to choose a TEAM from a specific GAME which you will give the award to. 

 

P.S Refer to examples in my list. Thanks

[sailboat]

done~ @Myrmidon Divergent

[Roswell]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - (Abstain) - The only one I'd vote for was the one I was in, so...
★ Best Mafia Coordination - WitchHunt [Coven]
★ Best Third Party Coordination - (Abstain) - The only one I'd vote for was the one I was in, so...

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - Megagun - CotOA
★ Best Mafia Performance - Purplecicada - WitchHunt
★ Best Third Party Performance - LykosHand - Pokemon: CYOC
★ Easiest Player to read - Alistair
★ Hardest Player to read - EndearingCharacterTrait
★ Always Town Award - Megagun
★ Always Mafia Award - (Abstain)
★ Most Tactical Player - Purplecicada
★ Most Interesting Player - Venus
★ Most Unfortunate Player - Alistair

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up - Pokemon: CYOC
★ Most Organized Game - CotOA
★ Favorite Game  - CotOA
★ Most Creative Host - Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Host - Myrmidon Divergent
★ The Judge Host - Myrmidon Divergent

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - LykosHand
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining - Myrmidon Divergent
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia - Alistair

 

Keep in mind that the main games that stick in my head are the ones I participated in, which is why some of the choices I made may seem odd.

Edited November 30, 2017 by Roswell
Changing to suit what Dive asked for

[Alistair]

Player Awards:

Team Category

 

★ Best Town Coordination - Keepers of the Onyx Arcade (Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade)
★ Best Mafia Coordination - Coven (WitchHunt)
★ Best Third Party Coordination - N's cult (Pokémon: choose your own character)

 

Individual Category

 

★ Best Town Performance - Myrmidon Divergent from DAM
★ Best Mafia Performance - Eviora from Star Wars
★ Best Third Party Performance - Sailboat from Pokémon
★ Easiest Player to read - Paul25
★ Hardest Player to read - Lord Drakyle
★ Always Town Award - LykosHand
★ Always Mafia Award - Megagun
★ Most Tactical Player - Eviora
★ Most Interesting Player - Venus
★ Most Unfortunate Player - Myrmidon Divergent

 

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

 

★ Most Interesting Set-up - Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Most Organized Game - Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Favorite Game - Dark Ages Mafia
★ Most Creative Host - Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Host - feels a bit weird to elect someone as "more interesting" than the others, so I'll pass
★ The Judge Host - Sailboat

 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

 

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - Quinn. But this question is just too hard. I also want to mention LykosHand, Anti_Hero, Hooligan, Newt, ECT and many others... not forgetting you guys. You're great people.
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining - can't pick only one person, sorry xD y'all are nuts.
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia - Myrmidon Divergent. I honestly couldn't choose between you and Quinn, you have both done a lot for us all. I considered not voting for anyone, but I figured supporting one of you was better than supporting no one, so I flipped a coin, and here is the result =p

[LykosHand]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade [Keepers]
★ Best Mafia Coordination: Coven [WitchHunt]
★ Best Third Party Coordination: Wild West Showdown Mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Quinnox [Reborn Girls "Fight for love" Mafia]
★ Best Mafia Performance: purplecicada [WitchHunt]
★ Best Third Party Performance: Sailboat [Choose your Own Character! Mafia]
★ Easiest Player to read: Paul25
★ Hardest Player to read: Lord Drakyle
★ Always Town Award: Paul25
★ Always Mafia Award: Venus
★ Most Tactical Player: Myrmidom Divergent
★ Most Interesting Player: Alistair
★ Most Unfortunate Player: Alistair

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Choose your Own Character! Mafia
★ Most Organized Game: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Favorite Game: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Most Creative Host: Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Host: Alistair
★ The Judge Host: Sailboat

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly: Alistair (but even Quinnox, Anti_Hero, Hooligan and more people)
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining: Myrmidon Divergent
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia: Anti_Hero

Please don't be angry if i didn't vote for some of you, i swear to you that it wasn't a simple decision.

[Daniel Blackworth]

Bumped

[Megagun]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Witch Hunt!

★ Best Mafia Coordination: Hospital Mafia
★ Best Third Party Coordination: Pokemon Choose your own Character

Individual Category

 

★ Best Town Performance

★ Best Mafia Performance: 
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read: Venus
★ Hardest Player to read: Greninja (For no other reason than you too quiet)
★ Always Town Award: 
★ Always Mafia Award
★ Most Tactical Player: Divergent
★ Most Interesting Player: Jace Stormkirk
★ Most Unfortunate Player: Alistair('ed)

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Trouble in Fire Emblem.
★ Most Organized Game: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Favorite Game: Dark Ages Mafia!
★ Most Creative Host
★ Most Interesting Host
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly: 
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining: Venus
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia

Edited December 3, 2017 by Megagun

[Anime]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination???
★ Best Mafia Coordination Witch hunt (coven)
★ Best Third Party Coordination ???

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance ???
★ Best Mafia Performance Nicki from witchhunt
★ Best Third Party Performance ???
★ Easiest Player to read Lykos
★ Hardest Player to read sailboat
★ Always Town Award ???
★ Always Mafia Award ???
★ Most Tactical Playe Drak
★ Most Interesting Player Dive
★ Most Unfortunate Player Alistair

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up Chronicles
★ Most Organized Game Chronicles of onix arcade
★ Favorite Game Witch hunt
★ Most Creative Host Kiyo
★ Most Interesting Host Sailboat
★ The Judge Host ???

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly Drak
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining Yin
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia Venus

 

Edited December 6, 2017 by Amine Chankey3ft7

[Guest Sparkin']

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Hospital Mafia
★ Best Mafia Coordination: Star Wars Mafia
★ Best Third Party Coordination: N's Cult/Pokémon Mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Megagun in Hospital Mafia
★ Best Mafia Performance: Eviora in Star Wars Mafia
★ Best Third Party Performance: Megagun in Hospital Mafia
★ Easiest Player to read: Myrmidon Divergent
★ Hardest Player to read: Alistair
★ Always Town Award: Anti_Hero
★ Always Mafia Award: Megagun
★ Most Tactical Player: Lord Drakyle
★ Most Interesting Player: Alistair
★ Most Unfortunate Player: Myrmidon Divergent

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Chronicles of Onyx Arcade
★ Most Organized Game:
★ Favorite Game: 
★ Most Creative Host:
★ Most Interesting Host:
★ The Judge Host: 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly:
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining:
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia:

Edited December 3, 2017 by Sparkin'

[Newt]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Hospital Mafia
★ Best Mafia Coordination: -
★ Best Third Party Coordination: -

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Hospital Mafia (Corso)
★ Best Mafia Performance: -
★ Best Third Party Performance: - Hospital Mafia (Megagun)
★ Easiest Player to read: Venus
★ Hardest Player to read: Alistair
★ Always Town Award: Lykos
★ Always Mafia Award: Megagun
★ Most Tactical Player: Eviora
★ Most Interesting Player: Venus
★ Most Unfortunate Player: Alistair

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Most Organized Game: Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade
★ Favorite Game: Hospital Mafia
★ Most Creative Host: Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Host: Myrmidon Divergent
★ The Judge Host: Anti_Hero

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly: LykosHand
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining: Venus
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia: Alistair

Edited December 2, 2017 by Dark Rogue

[Daniel Blackworth]

@Megagun For Most Interesting Set-up, you choose a specific game.

 

@Amine Chankey3ft7 One person / game per award. For Best Mafia Performance, you need to mention the game as well.

 

@Venus @Dark Rogue Specific person for Hospital Mafia? (Best Town Performance)

 

 

 

[Corso]

I participated only in 4 games out of 14, so I'm not sure if I should vote

 

Spoiler

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination 
★ Best Mafia Coordination
★ Best Third Party Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance 
★ Best Mafia Performance          Eviora from Star Wars Mafia 
★ Best Third Party Performance  Megagun from Hospital Mafia
★ Easiest Player to read                               
★ Hardest Player to read            Venus                             
★ Always Town Award                                       
★ Always Mafia Award                                                   
★ Most Tactical Player                Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Player           Lord Drakyle
★ Most Unfortunate Player                 
                                                         
Host and Mafia Game Awards:       
                                                           
★ Most Interesting Set-up           Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade Mafia
★ Most Organized Game                                   
★ Favorite Game                        Hospital Mafia                          
★ Most Creative Host                                   
★ Most Interesting Host              Myrmidon Divergent
★ The Judge Host                                            
                                                                       
Reborn Mafia Awards:                                          
                                                                         
★ Mr./Ms. Friendly                      LykosHand
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining                Dark Rogue
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia              Alistair

 

[Guest Sparkin']

@Myrmidon Divergent: Edited. Though I'm not sure if it's allowed, since Megagun was amnesiac before becoming ECT

[Paul25]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - Mafia: Trouble in Fire Emblem

★ Best Mafia Coordination - Star Wars
★ Best Third Party Coordination - Pokemon: Cboose Your Own Character Mafia [N's cult]

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - Mafia : Halloween edition [Myrmidon Divergent]
★ Best Mafia Performance - Star Wars [Eviora] 
★ Best Third Party Performance - Pokemon: Choose Your Own Character [Lykoshand] 
★ Easiest Player to read - Megagun
★ Hardest Player to read - Eviora
★ Always Town Award -  Lykoshand
★ Always Mafia Award - Megagun
★ Most Tactical Player - Quinnox
★ Most Interesting Player - Alistair
★ Most Unfortunate Player - Alistair

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up - Chronicles of Arcade Mafia [Myrmidon Divergent]
★ Most Organized Game - Chronicles of Arcade Mafia [Myrmidon Divergent]
★ Favorite Game - Mafia : Trouble in Fire Emblem [Jace Stormkirk]
★ Most Creative Host - Myrmidon Divergent
★ Most Interesting Host - Myrmidon Divergent
★ The Judge Host - Quinnox
 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - Lykoshand
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining - Alistair
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia - Quinnox

 

Note: I'd different opinions about whom to vote in most and therefore, I hurriedly chose between them without wasting much time.

I'm Sorry for those, whose names I didn't mention.

Edited December 5, 2017 by Paul25
Recorrected

[Daniel Blackworth]

@Paul25 For Best Town and Mafia Coordination, you cannot vote for a team you were part of.

[Megagun]

I've changed what was needed and added one of my empty slots, Most Entertaining Player@Myrmidon Divergent

[Paul25]

@Myrmidon Divergent, Thanks for notifying that, successfully corrected it.

May have missed that line while reading your presentaction as I read that leniently.

[Anti_Hero]

Player Awards:

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - Chronicles of the Onyx Arcade Mafia 6 Monthversary
★ Best Mafia Coordination - Star Wars
★ Best Third Party Coordination - Pokemon: Cboose Your Own Character Mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - 
★ Best Mafia Performance - Megagun - werewolf
★ Best Third Party Performance - ECT - Coyote
★ Easiest Player to read - Lykoshand
★ Hardest Player to read - Drakyle
★ Always Town Award - Paul
★ Always Mafia Award - Venus
★ Most Tactical Player - Megagun
★ Most Interesting Player - Purple
★ Most Unfortunate Player - Quinnox killing herself in the pokemon mafia

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up -  WitchHunt! 
★ Most Organized Game - 6 monthverssary its not the official name but i prefer this
★ Favorite Game - Halloween
★ Most Creative Host - Jace
★ Most Interesting Host - Dive
★ The Judge Host - Jace

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Mr./Ms. Friendly - Lykoshand
★ Mr./Ms. Entertaining - Alistair
★ Mr./Ms. Reborn Mafia - Quinnox

[Alistair]

Time's up, friends.

 

This voting thread is for now locked to further replies. Thanks to everyone who cast their votes for this first Mafia awards edition! Results will be released in an indefinite time, but please look forward to them~