Jump to content

Hurt and Heal: Starter Pokemon Lines (Winner: Piplup with 18(!) points)


Jess

Recommended Posts

  • Veterans

Bulbasaur: 25

Charmander: 13

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 23

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 16

Torchic: 15

Mudkip: 27

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 20

Snivy: 19

Tepig: 9

Oshawott: 18

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 20

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

 

I'll be putting my vote for today down now. Cynda ftw

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

24 minutes ago, Jess said:

Can't agree more. Greninja is supposed to transform into Ash-Gren due to an extremely strong bond with its trainer (story-wise). So, if my Greninja bonds a lot with me, it won't turn into me (the respective selected main character form), but into fucking Ash Ketchum. Fuck logic.

I'm ok with the idea of battle bond I think they just fucked up the execution of it for the main games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur : 23

Charmander: 13

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 16

Torchic: 15

Mudkip: 27

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 20

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 18

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 20

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal Rowlet & Hurt Mudkip

 

Bulbasaur : 23

Charmander: 13

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 16

Torchic: 15

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 20

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 18

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 21

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Torchic needs to die.

 

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 11

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 16

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 18

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 21

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 11

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 16

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 20

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 18

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 19

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ash gren was a mistake. The idea itself wan;t terrible, granted it wasn't a good idea either, but making it exclusive to Greninja is where it went to shit. and them making it look like Ash instead of a player character... at this point just give it a mega already

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 11

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 20

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 22

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 20

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 19

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

 

Hurt Treecko, Heal Oshawott

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 11

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 22

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 21

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 19

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 11

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 22

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 16

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My biggest problem with ash gren is that it takes away the most unique and fun part of greninja and it's protean. That and also the fact that's it takes no mega slot for some reason, It's stupid and bullshit and boring and should have stayed in the anime were it belongs. That said I can't downvote froakie right now, it's a well designed pokemon with a great movepool and an awesome ability, Much worse starters are still on the list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why the hate on the Charmander-Line? Who would hurt such a cute beeing ;)

519630426110184355_485504625_1419055893.

 

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 22

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 14

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 18

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, HAWmaro said:

My biggest problem with ash gren is that it takes away the most unique and fun part of greninja and it's protean. That and also the fact that's it takes no mega slot for some reason, It's stupid and bullshit and boring and should have stayed in the anime were it belongs. That said I can't downvote froakie right now, it's a well designed pokemon with a great movepool and an awesome ability, Much worse starters are still on the list.

If all starters had Battle Bond and the boost wasn;t as big as it is it would not be a terrible idea. And ofcourse don't make it focus on Ash...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 23

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 14

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 16

Popplio: 19

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why are you even targeting Chespin? It's one of the cutest starters and the final evo is actually strong. 

 

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 19

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 15

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 16

Popplio: 19

 

If we try to categorise the starters (and disregard megas), the easy way to do so is this: 
Monsters: Blaziken, Greninja

Very Strong: Feraligatr, Swampert, Infernape, Serperior

Strong: Chesnaught, Primarina, Empoleon, Decidueye, Delphox

Mediocre: Samurott, Emboar, Incineroar, Charizard, Venusaur, Typhlosion, Sceptile
Weak: Meganium, Blastoise, Torterra

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 17

Tepig : 9

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 15

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 16

Popplio: 20

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, NickCrash said:

Why are you even targeting Chespin? It's one of the cutest starters and the final evo is actually strong.

i don't categorize them in strong and weak. His final Evolution just doesn't appeal to me.

It's the same thing for Blaziken, Blastoise and Emboar. I don't like their actual design.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 25

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 17

Tepig : 7

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 15

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 16

Popplio: 21

 

Let's go Popplio-chan,woo hoo !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, NickCrash said:

If we try to categorise the starters (and disregard megas), the easy way to do so is this: 
Monsters: Blaziken, Greninja

Very Strong: Feraligatr, Swampert, Infernape, Serperior

Strong: Chesnaught, Primarina, Empoleon, Decidueye, Delphox

Mediocre: Samurott, Emboar, Incineroar, Charizard, Venusaur, Typhlosion, Sceptile
Weak: Meganium, Blastoise, Torterra

Wow. That's very well put. And when you do factor in megas, Swampert becomes a monster (especially in the rain).

Then I think the megas would fit in something like this:

Swampert: Very Strong -> Monster

Sceptile: Mediocre-> Very Strong

Charizard: Mediocre -> Both X and Y = Very Stong

Venusaur: Mediocre -> Very Strong

Blastoise: Weak -> Mediocre

And Blaziken stays broken.

 

18 minutes ago, CrimsonDragon21 said:

i don't categorize them in strong and weak. His final Evolution just doesn't appeal to me.

Same. Well I do tend to factor in competitive ability but I just kinda find the Chespin line to be overall kinda ugly. And really, the only reason it's somewhat effective is because it's a good spikes user. Bad 'mon if you ask me.

 

16 minutes ago, walpurgis said:

Snivy has contrary so it actually should be gaining two points every time someone hurts it. 

lol. But if that's true then at the end of every day Torchic should gain a point (Speed Boost).

Edited by Dragoknight
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No mercy.

Also, I am Mudkip's eternal hype man.

 

-2 Tepig, +1 Mudkip

Bulbasaur: 24

Charmander: 12

Squirtle: 10

Cyndaquil: 24

Totodile: 18

Treecko: 14

Torchic: 13

Mudkip: 26

Turtwig: 21

Chimchar: 20

Piplup: 21

Snivy: 17

Tepig : 5

Oshawott: 20

Chespin: 15

Fennekin: 19

Froakie: 20

Rowlet: 17

Litten: 16

Popplio: 21

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally, competitive ability doesn't matter at all. I vote solely based on how well-thought and well-designed a 'mon is (in my opinion).

Overrated/too strong Pokemon tend to not be very liked by me though, just because of the "overhype" factor...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...