Jump to content

Season 2 Reborn Mafia Awards Voting Thread


Recommended Posts

Season 2 Reborn Mafia Awards Voting Thread

 

Another 6 months of playing Mafia has passed yet again and it is now the time for this season to end. As we look back on the memories we've shared with our fellow clubmates, we may remember a specific game that stood out to us or recall players who performed excellently. We may also admire certain lovable and amazing hosts or acknowledge the coordination of a team of players. As this season closes, we recognize their efforts through the Reborn Mafia Awards!

 

Rules for Voting:

Spoiler

(1) All 20 games, beginning with League of Legends Mafia until A Trip down Memory Lane, are eligible for voting in terms of the games themselves and their respective hosts and players.


(2) Voters must have played at least one game in Season 2 to be eligible for voting.

(3) Voters must copy the voting sheet and indicate their votes on the respective categories for their votes to count. They may fill in selected categories or place a vote on all categories. Only one vote will be acknowledged per Award.

(4) Voters may not vote for themselves, nor are they allowed to vote for a team which they were a member of or a game they hosted.

(5) All voting will be done in the thread. Voters may change or edit their votes in the duration of the voting session, but they must notify me regarding changes.

(6) Voters may or may not explain the reason for their votes.

(7) The Voting Session will end on June 1, 2018. If you wish to vote, please do so before the aforementioned date.

 

Eligible Games:

Spoiler

(1) League of Legends Mafia [TOWN] - Quinn

 

(2) A Nintendo Battle Royale! [MAFIA] - Jace Stormkirk

 

(3) The Great War at Little Italy [TOWN] - LykosHand

 

(4) End of a Journey! [THIRD PARTY] - Sailboat

 

(5) Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game [MAFIA] - Venus

 

(6) Circus Mafia [THIRD PARTY] - Digital Amber

 

(7) Owner's Market [MAFIA] - Alisae

 

(8) Love at First Lie: A Chronicles Sidestory [THIRD PARTY] - Divergent

 

(9) Mafia: The Temporal Turmoil [TOWN] - Newt

 

(10) Back to the Basics I: Diffusion of Power [MAFIA] - Divergent

 

(11) Shining Bright: Survivor [THIRD PARTY] - Bazaro

 

(12) Blind Mafia [MAFIA] - Lord Drakyle

 

(13) Bullet Hell Mafia [TOWN] - Digital Amber

 

(14) Fire Emblem: Heroes [THIRD PARTY] - Venus

 

(15) Battle Royale: Pokemon Reborn Edition [THIRD PARTY] - Divergent

 

(16) Keyboard Warriors: A Mafia Game [TOWN] - Sailboat

 

(17) Riddle Mafia [MAFIA] - Jace Stormkirk

 

(18) Clue Mafia - Quinn

 

(19) Mafia: What lurks below - Alaris

 

(20) A Trip down Memory Lane [MAFIA] - Divergent

 

* Words in brackets represent the winning faction of each game.

 

There have been some changes in terms of awards after a discussion done by the moderators. Here are the changes:

Spoiler

The following awards have been removed:

* Best Third Party Coordination

* Always Town Award

* Always Mafia Award

* Most Unfortunate Award

 

The following awards have been changed:

* Most Interesting Host -> Best Flavor Writer

* Mr./Ms. Friendly and Mr./Ms. Entertaining -> Jack of Clubs

* Mr./Ms. Reborn -> Queen of Hearts and King of Spades

 

The following awards have been added:

* Best Newcomer

* Ace of Diamonds

 

Award Descriptions:

Spoiler

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination - An award given to the most dedicated and connected town group coordination in a specific game.
★ Best Mafia Coordination - An award given to the most united and deceitful mafia group coordination in a specific game.

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance - An award given to the most trustworthy and strategic town performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Best Mafia Performance - An award given to the most deceitful and convincing mafia performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Best Third Party Performance - An award given to the most masterful third party performance of a player in a specific game.
★ Easiest Player to read - An award given to the player whom you can read like an open book or easily associate with an alignment.
★ Hardest Player to read - An award given to the player who is difficult to understand in terms of alignment and motives.
★ Most Tactical Player - An award given to the most strategic player and the best when it comes to reading other players.
★ Most Interesting Player - An award given to the most exciting player or the player who always manages to shake things up.

★ Best Newcomer - An award given to the best newcomer player who started playing Mafia in Season 2. 

Spoiler

Eligible Newcomers:

 

* Alaris  
* L'Belle  
* Crimson Dragon 
* Hooligan 
* Castiel101 
* walpurgis 
* Bazaro
* Mr. Knightly
* pcmay 
* Bok Choi
* Nick Crash
* Filthy Casual 
* Alisae 
* Dilion Eicieco 
* splargle 
* Chromein 
* Hypurr 


Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up - An award given to the game with the most interesting role combinations and mechanics.
★ Most Organized Game - An award given to the most well-organized game in terms of aspects such as deadlines, announcements, night action interaction, and other related notions.
★ Favorite Game - An award given to your personal favorite game.
★ Most Creative Host - An award given to the host who comes up with the most creative mechanics and concepts for their games.
★ Best Flavor Writer - An award given to the host who produces the best narratives and storylines.
★ The Judge Host - An award given to the most impartial and fair host in terms of relating to players and factions. 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs - An award given to the friendliest and most relatable member of the club
★ Queen of Hearts - An award given to a female member, who you feel, has positively contributed the most to the Reborn Mafia Club.

★ King of Spades - An award given to a male member, who you feel, has positively contributed the most to the Reborn Mafia Club.
★ Ace of Diamonds - An award given to the overall best player of the season. [predetermined and not to be voted upon]

 

Voting Sheet:

Spoiler

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read
★ Hardest Player to read
★ Most Tactical Player
★ Most Interesting Player
★ Best Newcomer

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up
★ Most Organized Game
★ Favorite Game
★ Most Creative Host
★ Best Flavor Writer
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs
★ Queen of Hearts
★ King of Spades

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Best Newcomer - An award given to the  - I think this needs completed.

And The Queen of Hearts and King of Spades say the same thing (I'm assuming King of Spades needs to be changed to male)

(And if I'm being subjective here, I feel like the most interesting player reads better if always is before manages i.e. Or the player who always manages to shake things up).

 

Will put in my vote later on.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination temporal turmoil
★ Best Mafia Coordination riddle mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance megagun [riddle mafia]
★ Best Third Party Performance love at first lie
★ Easiest Player to read newt
★ Hardest Player to read lykoshand
★ Most Tactical Player alaris
★ Most Interesting Player nick crash
★ Best Newcomer lia

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up daganrompa
★ Most Organized Game
★ Favorite Game
★ Most Creative Host venus
★ Best Flavor Writer
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs nick crash
★ Queen of Hearts nicki
★ King of Spades lykoshand

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Jace Stormkirk I think you need to name a specific player for all awards in the individual category

 

As for my votes:

Spoiler

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Coordination A Trip Down Memory Lane

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance Lord Drakyle in Bullet Hell
★ Best Mafia Performance Candy in Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Best Third Party Performance Venus in Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Easiest Player to read Bean
★ Hardest Player to read Venus
★ Most Tactical Player Divergent
★ Most Interesting Player NickCrash
★ Best Newcomer Walpurgis aka Lía

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up Reborn Battle Royale
★ Most Organized Game Love at First Lie
★ Favorite Game Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Most Creative Host Alaris for Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Best Flavor Writer Divergent for Love at First Lie
★ The Judge Host Quinn for LoL mafia

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs LykosHand
★ Queen of Hearts Walpurgis aka Lía
★ King of Spades Divergent

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination [Temporal Turmoil]
★ Best Mafia Coordination [Back to the Basics I: Diffusion of Power]

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance 
★ Best Mafia Performance [LykosHand from Owner's Market]
★ Best Third Party Performance [Alistair from Circus Mafia]
★ Easiest Player to read [Newt]
★ Hardest Player to read [Corso]
★ Most Tactical Player [Alaris]
★ Most Interesting Player [Venus]
★ Best Newcomer [Alaris]

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up [Fire Emblem: Heroes]
★ Most Organized Game [Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game]
★ Favorite Game [Fire Emblem: Heroes]
★ Most Creative Host [Venus]
★ Best Flavor Writer
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs [LykosHand]
★ Queen of Hearts [Walpurgis]
★ King of Spades [Alistair]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: 
★ Best Mafia Coordination: 

 

Individual Category
★ Best Town Performance: 

★ Best Mafia Performance: 

★ Best Third Party Performance: Venus in Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Easiest Player to read 
★ Hardest Player to read Dive
★ Most Tactical Player Alaris
★ Most Interesting Player Venus
★ Best Newcomer:
Alaris

 

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Most Organized:
 [Epilogue] A Trip down Memory Lane
★ Favorite Game: Reborn Battle Royale

★ Most Creative Host: Alaris for Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Best Flavor Writer: Alaris for Mafia: What Lurks Below (pre-newspaper's guy death)

★ The Judge Host: 

 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs: LykosHand
★ Queen of Hearts: Cat
★ King of Spades: Dive

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Mafia: The Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Coordination: Blind Mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Lord Drakyle in Bullet Hell
★ Best Mafia Performance: Candy in Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Best Third Party Performance: Venus in Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ Easiest Player to read: Bean
★ Hardest Player to read: NickCrash
★ Most Tactical Player: Alaris
★ Most Interesting Player: NickCrash
★ Best Newcomer: Walpurgis

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Organized Game: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Favorite Game: Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Creative Host: Venus for Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Best Flavor Writer: Alaris for Mafia: What Lurks Below
★ The Judge Host: Quinn for League of Legends Mafia

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs: Alistair
★ Queen of Hearts: Walpurgis
★ King of Spades: Mazino Divergent

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance
★ Best Third Party Performance
★ Easiest Player to read
★ Hardest Player to read
★ Most Tactical Player Venus
★ Most Interesting Player Bean
★ Best Newcomer  Walpurgis

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Organized Game 
★ Favorite Game Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Creative Host Venus
★ Best Flavor Writer Dive
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs
★ Queen of Hearts Quinn
★ King of Spades Venus

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance- 
★ Best Mafia Performance- Owner's market
★ Best Third Party Performance- Circus Mafia
★ Easiest Player to read
★ Hardest Player to read
★ Most Tactical Player Venus
★ Most Interesting Player Bean
★ Best Newcomer  Walpurgis

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting What Lies Below
★ Most Organized Game- Shining Bright
★ Favorite Game- End of a Journey
★ Most Creative Host Venus
★ Best Flavor Writer Dive
★ The Judge Host Sailboat

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs- Lykos
★ Queen of Hearts Quinn
 ★ King of Spades Dive

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Coordination: ---

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Walpurgis in Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Performance: Corso in Keyboard Warriors
★ Best Third Party Performance: Venus in What lurks below
★ Easiest Player to read: Mr. Knightly in Riddle Mafia
★ Hardest Player to read: Paul25 in most of the games
★ Most Tactical Player: NickCrash in A Trip down Memory Lane
★ Most Interesting Player: sailboat in What lurks below
★ Best Newcomer: Walpurgis

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Most Organized Game: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Favorite Game: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Most Creative Host: sailboat for Keyboard Warriors
★ Best Flavor Writer: Dive in A Trip down Memory Lane
★ The Judge Host: ---

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs: LyhosHand
★ Queen of Hearts: Walpurgis
★ King of Spades: Dive

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination: 
★ Best Mafia Coordination: Blind Mafia

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Walpurgis in Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Performance: 
★ Best Third Party Performance: Venus in what Lurks Below
★ Easiest Player to read: 
★ Hardest Player to read: LykosHand in Riddle Mafia
★ Most Tactical Player: Dive
★ Most Interesting Player: Venus
★ Best Newcomer: Alaris

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: What Lies Below.
★ Most Organized Game: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Favorite Game: Reborn Battle Royale
★ Most Creative Host: Venus
★ Best Flavor Writer: Alaris
★ The Judge Host: 

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs: LykosHand
★ Queen of Hearts: Walpurgis
★ King of Spades: Dive

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination:
Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Coordination: --

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance: Walpurgis in Temporal Turmoil
★ Best Mafia Performance: Alistair in Love at First Lie (unsure if counted as mafia or third party)
★ Best Third Party Performance: Divergent in Fire Emblem: Heroes
★ Easiest Player to read: Newt
★ Hardest Player to read: NickCrash
★ Most Tactical Player: Alaris
★ Most Interesting Player: Bean
★ Best Newcomer: Alaris

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up: Danganronpa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Organized Game: Battle Royale: Pokemon Reborn Edition
★ Favorite Game: The ones where I win  Battle Royale: Pokemon Reborn Edition
★ Most Creative Host: Venus
★ Best Flavor Writer: Divergent
★ The Judge Host: --

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs: Bean
★ Queen of Hearts: Walpurgis
★ King of Spades: LykosHand

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Player Awards:


Team Category

★ Best Town Coordination
★ Best Mafia Coordination

Individual Category

★ Best Town Performance
★ Best Mafia Performance
★ Best Third Party Performance Alistair in Love at First Lie
★ Easiest Player to read FilthyCasual
★ Hardest Player to read Walpurgis
★ Most Tactical Player
Alistair
★ Most Interesting Player Bean
★ Best Newcomer Walpurgis

Host and Mafia Game Awards:

★ Most Interesting Set-up Danganrompa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Organized Game Love at First Lie
★ Favorite Game Danganrompa: The Ultimate Killing Game
★ Most Creative Host Venus
★ Best Flavor Writer Dive
★ The Judge Host

Reborn Mafia Awards:

★ Jack of Clubs LykosHand
★ Queen of Hearts Walpurgis
★ King of Spades Alistair

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...