Jump to content

The Odd One Out -- A Reborn Story


Aphelli

Should I keep uploading pictures for the chapters?  

13 members have voted

  1. 1. Should I keep uploading pictures for the chapters?

    • Yes, you can even add more!
      11
    • Try and make less of them.
      2
    • It's better without pictures altogether.
      0
  2. 2. Should I keep uploading pictures for main battles?

    • Yes, keep them about the in-game battles.
      7
    • Try and post some about how the battles are narrated.
      5
    • No, the story is self-sufficient.
      1

This poll is closed to new votes


Recommended Posts

Page changes is tricky so I can't quote that well.

 

About the hug: I agree. In the text, it's sort of a blind spot (an issue of first-person narration, the blind spots are really blind) of the character, so it's never really mentioned because he doesn't even acknowledge that as a possibility. So Gabriel is probably not going to give them a hug. He's not really the hugging type. 

 

Or perhaps I'll rethink that. I don't know. 

 

It doesn't mean that he won't try to find some other ways, no less sincere but perhaps more... unusual, to help them. I'd say a little more but then that would spoil the next chapter. 

 

These dark scenes are overall difficult to write. I need to remember who's thinking of what, who's ready to go to what lengths. To find sensible plans for the bad guys, and why the good guys don't just all die because they thought it was going to be straightforward. Also, that negative emotions so intense leave dire consequences, otherwise it's just edge.

 

Sigh... this is going to get depressing, isn't it? I really wanted it to take more time...

 

A little note on Evi's comment about Sirius. I think it's important to keep in mind that it's a blessing that Sirius isn't there. Because Sirius, especially since he knows they're coming, isn't going to challenge them in a Pokemon fight. He's just going to spring a trap. 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

I don't want to think of the specifics right now, but I'm pretty sure it wouldn't take much effort to find plausible courses of action for Sirius that would lead to a "total party kill".  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Hello! 

 

I hope you're doing well. 

 

It's been a busy ten days, and I think this isn't likely to change in the near future -- although hopefully I'll have less pressure. Because what's the point of summer vacation if not to have the time to properly study enough to acquire the knowledge you need? 

 

Wait... am I getting this backwards? 

 

Anyway, here's the last chapter of the Yureyu sequence, whose consequences on the characters I hadn't fully realized until I started thinking of what came next. I wish I had managed to get a bit more ahead in the planning, but it is what it is...

 

 

Chapter 53: Encore

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Character rates:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

Death count:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Player's note:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Hey! 

 

I hope you're all doing well. 

 

This is the 128th post, an amazing number -- thank you to all of you who helped me keep making progress!

 

I've had an idea for the story in the past few days, for a little difference in the plot... but I don't know if it's a good one, because it's, well, different, in ways I'm not sure I fully understand. Its climax isn't happening before 10 chapters at the very least, but I don't have a good idea of the specifics of what happens until then... and I have very little idea of whether it can have a noncontrived satisfactory resolution. I suppose it's better since it involves more "moving pieces", but, still... I wish I didn't have to decide on that soon, but I feel like I sort of do...

 

Anyway. A new chapter is here, and we'll be taking a little rest from the action and the overall madness. So it's a little self-reflection, and there's another glimpse of a character we haven't heard of in some 20 chapters... To be fully honest, that's a chapter whose idea I stumbled upon as I was writing the former one (so 53), and... I didn't realize I wanted this written that badly. It may be one of the chapters I've managed to write the fastest. 

 

As usual, I appreciate any feedback that you may give -- a reaction here or on the Discord announcement, a comment (wait am I watching youtube too much these days) -- including if it's about an older chapter because that's what you're currently reading. 

 

 

Enjoy!

 

I just remembered: the chapters contains spoilers for Prisoner of Azkaban and some background information from pre-1945 Potterverse history that I don't think is a real spoiler. But if you want to discover everything about Harry Potter by yourself, you should start reading after the first star.   

 

 

I just remembered bis: there is a mention of a "day of the week" information in this chapter. I thought I had included some in earlier chapters, but I can't see it at all. If you remember or can find one, please comment. If it contradicts the information given in this chapter, it's not too bad either (but I kind of like when everything is consistent so I would really like to know). 

 

 

Chapter 54: After Hours

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ouch, this chapter was probably the most depressing one so far after listing to all the thoughts now.

 

But I never expected Noel to act like that, which scared me a little and the fact, they haven't retrieved their teams yet... Charlotte's and Anna's parts were sad, with the former playing a tragic tune on it.

 

However now, when Saphira will appear things will turn ugly for Gabriel, since we know how our Dragon Queen ticks, when it comes to her remaining family.

 

  On 6/15/2021 at 10:33 PM, Mindlack said:

So she had called a lawyer that she knew, just to make sure that Saphira's story would stand in the obvious ensuing libel suit. It was a wholesale slaughter. Saphira on a witness chair was... wrong. Powerlessness did not suit her at all. In less than two hours, she had been reduced to a red-eyed mess, clenching her fists so hard that her nails were biting into her palms, who knew -- and couldn't do much about it -- that she was just dancing on the lawyer's strings, excellently arguing against herself.

Expand  

 

  On 6/15/2021 at 10:33 PM, Mindlack said:

Anna was lying in bed, her eyes wide awake. It wasn't too much about her traumatic experiences of the past years. Instead, she felt overflowing with energy, much better than she could ever remember. She was free at last! Free from the Doctor, from the "therapy" that he imposed on her several times per week, deaf to her pleas and her suffering. If she saw things that no one else could, that didn't mean she had to be shocked -- why couldn't he comprehend that?

 

 

Expand  

Ouch, given how much of a dickhead and "cruel" person Sigmund is, I wouldn't be suprised about his treatment might have ruined the children... Especially Anna (with her powers) and Saphira (still waiting for the truth in E19)

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/15/2021 at 10:33 PM, Mindlack said:

"What do you think happens in City council? There are the incompetents, the cynics, the greedy, the corrupt and then us. Perhaps forty people total, so, us means, like, a dozen? But we do all the work. We're the ones who struggle to save Reborn. Every. Single. Day. We overwrite the incompetents' work. We nag the cynics into action. We keep the greedy in check, and force the corrupt few to pay dearly for the privilege they unlawfully took.

Expand  

You pretty nailed this part 10 out of 10, buddy. It perfectly voices Ame's hatred for those damm fools, who can get away from all of this mess, but not the good ones. That's very sad, if you can imagine that is also happens in the real world, which grinds me a lot😡

 

I could imagine Ame snaping one day out of stress and anger, when trying to fix the mess. Also those corrupt idiots are almost in the same level as Team Meteor, if you ask me. It's.. very frightening and it always thr innocent who pay the price for it😭😡

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/16/2021 at 9:30 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Ouch, this chapter was probably the most depressing one so far after listing to all the thoughts now.

 

But I never expected Noel to act like that, which scared me a little and the fact, they haven't retrieved their teams yet... Charlotte's and Anna's parts were sad, with the former playing a tragic tune on it.

 

However now, when Saphira will appear things will turn ugly for Gabriel, since we know how our Dragon Queen ticks, when it comes to her remaining family.

Expand  

 

Oh dear... I worry that it says something about me that I didn't even consider it to be a sad chapter. 

 

For Noel: I think he's supposed to be “on the spectrum”, which implies that he can tend to think or react differently. As he's (when he speaks) pretty pragmatic and unemotional, I thought it was in character for him to view this ordeal as a price to pay -- and, all things considered, one he would be willing to. That doesn't mean that he won't suffer emotional consequences from everything that happened... perhaps they'll just take longer to appear or be deeper. I'm not exactly sure how or when, though. I just hope I'm not getting him utterly wrong. 

 

As for Saphira: this is going to be so fine... there's absolutely no need to worry... 🥴

 

 

 

  Quote

Ouch, given how much of a dickhead and "cruel" person Sigmund is, I wouldn't be suprised about his treatment might have ruined the children... Especially Anna (with her powers) and Saphira (still waiting for the truth in E19)

Expand  

 

This Sigmund is a little bit milder... I haven't settled on that yet. In canon, the children are rather well-adjusted: Saphira and Charlotte hate the guy and the others find him scary, which is rather superficial as far as psychology is concerned. So I think the Orphanage issues will be overshadowed by some more specific ones to each: Saphira and Charlotte have some sort of anger issues, Laura has something that may already be noticeable, and I'm not entirely sure about Heather (though canon is probably sound), Shelly (we'll see how this goes), Anna and Noel (I'm least sure about them tbf). 

 

 

  On 6/16/2021 at 4:07 PM, Evi Crystal said:

You pretty nailed this part 10 out of 10, buddy. It perfectly voices Ame's hatred for those damm fools, who can get away from all of this mess, but not the good ones. That's very sad, if you can imagine that is also happens in the real world, which grinds me a lot😡

 

I could imagine Ame snaping one day out of stress and anger, when trying to fix the mess. Also those corrupt idiots are almost in the same level as Team Meteor, if you ask me. It's.. very frightening and it always thr innocent who pay the price for it😭😡

Expand  

 

Thank you! I don't know how much of this is true in the real world. I guess that corruption happens even in first-world big cities. But here, I thought that everything should be up to eleven: how many people actually believe Reborn City can be fixed rather than live on out of inertia or "base" hedonism (and unwillingness to lay down and die)?

Everyone else is, on some level, a cynic. Some of them don't actually care (or don't realize deep-down what is on the verge of happening) and are in it for the money and the connections -- they're the greedy (or the corrupt for those who go to extra lengths). 

And of course, there has to be a good dose of incompetence because it's really unbelievable that Blacksteam could operate so long with a PULSE inside it. 

 

And yes, of course, the burden is on everyone else. 

 

But I don't see Ame snapping. She's far too aware of how important she is, has too much experience to lose her cool at important moments. And I guess she has people she can confide in (I suppose that voicing one's frustration at someone like Florinia, who will not react, can control it).   

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/16/2021 at 9:16 PM, Mindlack said:

As for Saphira: this is going to be so fine... there's absolutely no need to worry... 🥴

Expand  

*Jojo's voice* Ooh noooo😱😱

 

Run Gabriel! Ruuuuun, you and Cain will get both hyperbeamed all the way back to Azurine, if she finds out. Have mercy on these two fellas. I'll prefer Tania over Saphira despite some odds😶🙏🏼

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/16/2021 at 9:16 PM, Mindlack said:

For Noel: I think he's supposed to be “on the spectrum”, which implies that he can tend to think or react differently. As he's (when he speaks) pretty pragmatic and unemotional, I thought it was in character for him to view this ordeal as a price to pay -- and, all things considered, one he would be willing to. That doesn't mean that he won't suffer emotional consequences from everything that happened... perhaps they'll just take longer to appear or be deeper. I'm not exactly sure how or when, though. I just hope I'm not getting him utterly wrong.

Expand  

Sigh, Noel doesn't have it easy expression himself thanks to his condition. Kinda tragic and sad, what he and his sister went through such ordeal, but him more due to being overshadowed by her😔

 

I hope, they'll get their teams back soon because it will be upsetting since they bonded with them after so long despite being separated back then.

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/16/2021 at 9:48 PM, Evi Crystal said:

Have mercy on these two fellas. I'll prefer Tania over Saphira despite some odds😶🙏🏼

Expand  


Are you sure about that? Gabriel just went above and beyond to rescue Charlotte from an awful place. Whereas each time he worked with Amaria, Gabriel got out in a far better state than she did. 


But I will be merciful… after all, no more Gabriel means no more story, right? 


 

  On 6/16/2021 at 9:48 PM, Evi Crystal said:

*Jojo's voice* Ooh noooo😱😱

 

Run Gabriel! Ruuuuun, you and Cain will get both hyperbeamed all the way back to Azurine, if she finds out.

Expand  


That’s underestimating Saphira’s power. She’s going to Hyper Beam them to orbit instead.🤣

 

  On 6/17/2021 at 9:44 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Sigh, Noel doesn't have it easy expression himself thanks to his condition. Kinda tragic and sad, what he and his sister went through such ordeal, but him more due to being overshadowed by her😔

 

I hope, they'll get their teams back soon because it will be upsetting since they bonded with them after so long despite being separated back then.

Expand  


Yes, Noel doesn’t have it easy, does he? 
 

I think I can only answer all this comment by “Read the next chapters to find out!”

 

Or, I assume, wait until I finally get back to

1) finishing that >@$!?#%*!< chapter 55 that I seem to be plain unable to write

2) having a little more certainty on the next plot points

3) growing back my now-inexistant buffer


Sigh…

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2021 at 12:27 AM, Mindlack said:

Are you sure about that? Gabriel just went above and beyond to rescue Charlotte from an awful place. Whereas each time he worked with Amaria, Gabriel got out in a far better state than she did. 


But I will be merciful… after all, no more Gabriel means no more story, right? 

Expand  

 

Ah I didn't mean that for the Gabriel part😅

 

It just sometimes I have the mixed feelings with Tania and Saphira due to how their are and given their circumstances, but for me... Tania will be more calm in those instances despite her lack of empath and her anger (more than the latter) with Gabriel- expect for a certain situation with the something.

 

And we all know how Saphira is ticking, so I'm kinda worried about it, that she'll snap at him despite him rescuing Charlotte. She's not the type to be that easy after all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

This has been a long time, hasn't it? I hope you've been doing well. 

 

I've really been struggling on the chapters following the previous one, as I may have hinted multiple times. I'm not too sure why. And to top it all, I was hurting inside a little each time I saw Candy's frequent updates (or Derog's, I guess) -- always very good, while my writing is an uphill battle these days. 

Maybe it'll change now that I'm "on vacation". Maybe I need a true break from this too. I don't know. 

 

Still, the view counter keeps going up, and we're far past the amazing 15k views, so wow. 

 

I'll stop delaying and give you the chapter. Just a warning: it's a long one, and I'm not sure the quality matches the quantity. The plot is taking a little nap, but it's going to wake up soon... 

 

I hope you enjoy! (and if you do, please do react or comment, even about earlier chapters -- they're not too old to be relevant)

 

 

 

 

Chapter 55: Cultivating The Garden

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This chapter was overall relaxing and fun to read it after all the mess. I like the small wordbuilding of the Belrose Mansion and moments with Laura. Glad that Heather is showing some signs and that small moment with Shelly. It was cute, yet sad with all the horror of 4 days

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  On 7/28/2021 at 7:28 AM, Evi Crystal said:

This chapter was overall relaxing and fun to read it after all the mess. I like the small wordbuilding of the Belrose Mansion and moments with Laura. Glad that Heather is showing some signs and that small moment with Shelly. It was cute, yet sad with all the horror of 4 days

Expand  

 

Yes... these were some dark days indeed. They're thankfully over -- but I fear that they will still appear in some nightmares. I'm glad that there was still some cute upbeat stuff, even though it's definitely not my forte. Perhaps I should ask Azzie for lessons or something.

 

 

 

 

Anyway, I hope you enjoyed your summer (or, for at least one exception, that you will enjoy your hard-earned rest after a how-tf-can-it-still-be-legal internship)! Apparently you all kept reading or checking this story, and I'm very glad that you did. Thank you. 

 

As some of you might have read on discord or as a status update, it hasn't been the easiest time to write for me... but now summer break is over, I no longer have this excuse to avoid working on my thesis (I can still find others, but none that will let me write this instead^^), so perhaps it really was the best time. 

So I still wrote a lot of chapters in that time, and my "buffer" has grown to a length that has been unrivalled since the finale of Part 2. The difference is that I have lots and lots to edit, and a less clear picture of how the story goes on (spoiler: one sentence at a time). 

 

I'm pretty confident that this chapter isn't as good as it could be. But I'm tired, I'm feeling bad for not posting in some five weeks, and I don't think I'll be able to make good edits before another long time, so here it is. 

 

I hope you enjoy, and don't hesitate to comment either way!

 

 

Chapter 56: Business as Usual

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

Character rates:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Sad 2
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well... I cannot comment fully, because I'm crying over this chapter. I should've have expected this, but god dammit the outcome was- again- emotional for me. Poor Gabriel, never catch a break from all this mess😭💔

 

 

  On 8/30/2021 at 11:03 PM, Mindlack said:

"You bring harm to everyone you come into contact with." she explained, glaring at me so much that I lowered my eyes. "Florinia and Amaria nearly got killed. Charlotte and Heather got hurt because of you and Arceus knows if they'll recover. Corey and Kiki weren't as lucky."

"Corey killed himself." I protested weakly. "And he was working for Team Meteor."

"Yes, and he conveniently offed himself instead of explaining after his confrontations with you and no other witness that will speak about what happened!"

"I wish he had told me more too." I sighed.

"Don't change the topic." she snapped. "You're dangerous to everyone around you. So I'm not letting you harm my sisters in whichever way you seem to manage it. So go away."

Expand  

NO. NO. NO! Don't you dare blame him for that, Saphira! How could he know about the outcomes? He cannot predict them or do you think he has psychic powers?😡😡

 

I though Saphira might give him a beating given the type of a person she is, but I forgot about that as well. And it depicts Gabriel being always the scapegoat given he was involved with every affair of Team Meteor. Which makes it worse given his misfortunes😔

 

  On 8/30/2021 at 11:03 PM, Mindlack said:

It was starting to rain, but I was past caring about that. I sat down at some point, crying silently in the night. What was the point in going on? Even if I managed to find a way out of this new-concept labyrinth, would I just ride on the wings of disaster, the personification of an Absol? Would I still pretend to be virtuous fodder who miraculously survived for official eyes, yet sacrifice anyone and anything to save my own skin?

Expand  

Man... When you realise that even plot armour cannot heal emotional scars? Kinda reminds me of Harry Potter.

 

 

  On 8/30/2021 at 11:03 PM, Mindlack said:

I missed home. I missed math. I missed simplicity. I missed peace. I was so sick of this trip in Reborn that I had never wanted. Or at least, that I didn't remember desiring. I wanted to just stay here, letting go of everything, until the end.

Expand  

😔💔

 

 

Let's just hope, Gabriel will be fine and go through all this mess and perhaps finds some peace. Can wait for the parts with Citae Arc-d'Astrae Aerie and his interactions with Bennett, Elias, Adrienn and Radomus. This could be a turned point there. But I'm worry, that Elias might manipulating him despite being enemies. Who knows?

 

 

Also it was a good emotional chapter, buddy. Let's just hope everyone going to be fine expect for some nightmares and the upcoming raid. 

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Edit: added character rates to the previous chapter. 

 

Thank you Evi for your comment, and to all of you who reacted, here or on discord! 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Well... I cannot comment fully, because I'm crying over this chapter. I should've have expected this, but god dammit the outcome was- again- emotional for me. Poor Gabriel, never catch a break from all this mess😭💔

Expand  

 

Oh dear… I (repeat that I) am sorry for making you weep over Gabriel’s plight. 
Actually, Gabriel did get a small break, perhaps around 8 conscious hours? One has to take the good parts where they are… 

 

But yes, “Gabriel can’t catch a break” is so much a theme of this story that one could have guessed that chapter 55 wasn’t there to last. I don’t know when the next similar “chill” point is going to be, to be honest. It’ll probably be the end of Part 3, just before entering Agate. 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

NO. NO. NO! Don't you dare blame him for that, Saphira! How could he know about the outcomes? He cannot predict them or do you think he has psychic powers?😡😡

Expand  


Yes, I decided to make Saphira rather pro-active. She gathered all the info she could on Gabriel, and then decided she didn’t want him in her house. Not nice, but safe is better than sorry. 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

I though Saphira might give him a beating given the type of a person she is, but I forgot about that as well. And it depicts Gabriel being always the scapegoat given he was involved with every affair of Team Meteor. Which makes it worse given his misfortunes

Expand  

 

I decided that Saphira was more practical than that. Giving Gabriel a beating doesn’t do anything good to anyone – she gets angry for no good reason in the (quite possible, even to her) case where all the incidents have mundane causes. 
 

This may get explained at some point, and you might be able to figure this out on your own if you think along these lines, but Saphira 

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Man... When you realise that even plot armour cannot heal emotional scars? Kinda reminds me of Harry Potter.

😔💔

Expand  


But think how boring it would be if plot armor worked on emotions too… 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Let's just hope, Gabriel will be fine and go through all this mess and perhaps finds some peace.

Expand  

 

He will, don’t worry… at some unspecified point. 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Can wait for the parts with Citae Arc-d'Astrae Aerie and his interactions with Bennett, Elias, Adrienn and Radomus. This could be a turned point there. But I'm worry, that Elias might manipulating him despite being enemies. Who knows?

Expand  

 

I have some ideas for all of them, although they might require a little more thought. No comment (yet!) on El. 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Also it was a good emotional chapter, buddy.

Expand  

 

Thank you! It was pretty hard to write, I’m glad it came out the right way. 

 

  On 8/31/2021 at 9:41 AM, Evi Crystal said:

Let's just hope everyone going to be fine expect for some nightmares and the upcoming raid. 

 

Expand  


Ah. The raid… of course. (evil laughter) 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ooooookay, so, hi! I am here to read and to review your Reborn story for two reasons. One is because you have read and critiqued one of my own fanfiction stories (which I still appreciate and respect.)

 

Two is because now that I know that you've written a story of your own, or perhaps more than one that I have yet to become aware of, I feel that the time is ripe for me to repay the metaphorical favour and do so. Please note that I'll edit my review into this response because I am preemptively leaving my initial reply post here before my read through. Thanks again. :)

 

EDIT: I have now read up to Part 1, Chapter 23. I quite like your character dialogue, your battle style and the way that you write your scenes. In particular, I had really enjoyed your math solution entry into The Onyx Trainer's School, your Mosswater Factory battles and your Taka battles. I would like to see more instances where rests between battles are required (either by Pokemon Center rest area rooms, as Gabriel had used previously) or via town and/or city inns or hotels.

 

Also, I feel that the small but everyday things like morning routine requirements (daily showers, hair brushing, teeth cleaning, bathroom visit/s, breakfast) should be addressed every now and then, as well as essential item replacements and change/s of clothing and haircut/s. It is my hope that Gabriel and his team/s will gain confidence in himself and in their own selves and grow and develop to their fullest possible potential throughout this story.

Edited by Valyrian_Reforged
Reader's review #1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Thank you for reading and reviewing, @Valyrian_Reforged

 

To be honest, it was, sort of, one of the reasons why I reviewed your work: "if I don't read and review other people's work, why should my own be read?". But the question was asked abstractly, not in terms of an actual "quid pro quo" with an actual person. 

 

But this means that I will be your debtor for a while. 

 

Back on topic, I'm a little bit surprised you marked the end of chapter 23 (as opposed to the end of part 1, three chapters afterwards) as your first milestone. But breaks have to be taken, and if that felt the best place to stop for you, that's good to me. 

 

Thank you for your compliments.

 

I think I wanted the entry to the school to feel a little different, and since Gabriel is a math guy, the idea was there for the taking. I think (but it's so long ago now) that I was worried about it being a little outlandish. 

 

Mosswater Factory was actually interesting to plan. The idea is that my protagonist is sheltered, and is quite conflict-averse. So how do you storm an enemy base in these conditions? And how would the grunts of a terrorist organization react? These were the kind of questions driving me. 

 

 As for Taka... I have an idea for this character, so I won't go into too much detail (there's another battle with him coming next too). 

 

Rests between battles... I think this gets brought up later on, but not very often. I'm afraid that Gabriel isn't going to be an unstoppable force of nature... at least not yet. 

 

As for the little facts of life, I operate on story logic: most of them aren't that important or interesting, so they're mostly skipped, except perhaps at some rare times. If I remember correctly, there's a shower on chapter 27 (but he does try to shower every day). I think a toothbrush is mentioned in chapter 15, and you can assume that is used at least once a (usually dangerous) day. Clothes get brought up in chapter 15 too, if I remember well, and they sometimes get mentioned. But the story so far is pretty slow (in the current chapter [56], less than three weeks have happened since the train attack), so he won't change clothes that much. Also, he doesn't want to spend what little money he has for it, so he keeps the same ones (I guess we can assume he bought a little more underwear). 

 

Meals put me in a quandary (namely, what kind of food to write about? Berries sound insufficient for feeding, too, and the status of meat in Pokemon universes tends to be... awkward). Mostly you can assume that he grabs something that looks edible enough (and doesn't taste very good except maybe for the sugar) and a hot drink for breakfast. 

 

Gabriel has a very practical approach to hair (well, I hear that it's actually very flawed in real life but, well, my story, my rules): just pretend that it's worth the barest effort and it's going to be fine. I'll confess that I didn't think about haircuts. But time progresses quite slowly (up to chapter 23, there's barely a week spent in Reborn City) so there's little reason for him to get one yet. Maybe later, though. 

 

As for the bathroom breaks... let's say that I still am considering something that may well make you wish you never asked for it. ;)

 

No comment on the future chapters... I'll let you discover Gabriel's progress for yourself.

 

 

I regret to say that, while I appreciate your feedback, I will not incorporate it in the previously written chapters. Keeping moving is already difficult, and I don't have the strength to seriously rework my earlier chapters just yet. But I will definitely take that into account in the future. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 9/11/2021 at 10:35 PM, Mindlack said:

Thank you for reading and reviewing, @Valyrian_Reforged

 

To be honest, it was, sort of, one of the reasons why I reviewed your work: "if I don't read and review other people's work, why should my own be read?". But the question was asked abstractly, not in terms of an actual "quid pro quo" with an actual person. 

 

But this means that I will be your debtor for a while. 

 

Back on topic, I'm a little bit surprised you marked the end of chapter 23 (as opposed to the end of part 1, three chapters afterwards) as your first milestone. But breaks have to be taken, and if that felt the best place to stop for you, that's good to me. 

 

Thank you for your compliments.

 

I think I wanted the entry to the school to feel a little different, and since Gabriel is a math guy, the idea was there for the taking. I think (but it's so long ago now) that I was worried about it being a little outlandish. 

 

Mosswater Factory was actually interesting to plan. The idea is that my protagonist is sheltered, and is quite conflict-averse. So how do you storm an enemy base in these conditions? And how would the grunts of a terrorist organization react? These were the kind of questions driving me. 

 

 As for Taka... I have an idea for this character, so I won't go into too much detail (there's another battle with him coming next too). 

 

Rests between battles... I think this gets brought up later on, but not very often. I'm afraid that Gabriel isn't going to be an unstoppable force of nature... at least not yet. 

 

As for the little facts of life, I operate on story logic: most of them aren't that important or interesting, so they're mostly skipped, except perhaps at some rare times. If I remember correctly, there's a shower on chapter 27 (but he does try to shower every day). I think a toothbrush is mentioned in chapter 15, and you can assume that is used at least once a (usually dangerous) day. Clothes get brought up in chapter 15 too, if I remember well, and they sometimes get mentioned. But the story so far is pretty slow (in the current chapter [56], less than three weeks have happened since the train attack), so he won't change clothes that much. Also, he doesn't want to spend what little money he has for it, so he keeps the same ones (I guess we can assume he bought a little more underwear). 

 

Meals put me in a quandary (namely, what kind of food to write about? Berries sound insufficient for feeding, too, and the status of meat in Pokemon universes tends to be... awkward). Mostly you can assume that he grabs something that looks edible enough (and doesn't taste very good except maybe for the sugar) and a hot drink for breakfast. 

 

Gabriel has a very practical approach to hair (well, I hear that it's actually very flawed in real life but, well, my story, my rules): just pretend that it's worth the barest effort and it's going to be fine. I'll confess that I didn't think about haircuts. But time progresses quite slowly (up to chapter 23, there's barely a week spent in Reborn City) so there's little reason for him to get one yet. Maybe later, though. 

 

As for the bathroom breaks... let's say that I still am considering something that may well make you wish you never asked for it. ;)

 

No comment on the future chapters... I'll let you discover Gabriel's progress for yourself.

 

 

I regret to say that, while I appreciate your feedback, I will not incorporate it in the previously written chapters. Keeping moving is already difficult, and I don't have the strength to seriously rework my earlier chapters just yet. But I will definitely take that into account in the future. 

 

 

Expand  

 

Hi, Mindlack,

 

No worries. That's as good a reason as any to read and to critique a work, and/or works. In actuality, I had started at Chapter One. However, I had previously only thought to reply when I had read the entirety of this work. I'd decided against that upon receiving and reading your plentiful replies to my own work. Thank you for your feedback and support. I really enjoy reading your descriptions of Reborn City.

 

Your descriptions of each Ward and particularly of the PULSE Tangrowth damage had been most masterful. I like the way that you have really written your take upon the damage of these places and of the life and death struggle that it has been, thus far, for Gabriel.

 

He has been given a thankless job and you've had him ask questions that I feel that most protagonists never ask (such as why the Gym Leaders of Reborn haven't stepped in to help the protagonist against Team Meteor.) Cowardice and self preservation are the logical reasons behind why this is so. Gabriel is growing from cowardice into confidence and that's beautiful and admirable to see.

 

Thank you, in turn, for addressing the day to day minutiae that had been but a part of my immersion and practical concerns. I hadn't read that far ahead (to Chapter 56), but I'm glad that its mention was provided as an example to me.

 

Your revelation of the story pacing does explain alot as to why some of these concerns of mine hadn't been mentioned with regularity. I do remember reading about the toothbrush. I hadn't know about Gabriel's tooth brushing regularity, though. That is good to know.

 

Clothing is important. Changes of clothes is acceptable and definitely changes of underclothes are, even sporadically in Reborn, a must. Because it is currently a dump.

 

As to Gabriel's meals, I had read a very interesting fanfiction that had meals being created from some of the more plentiful Water critters of Pokemon (indeed an unsavoury practice), but in Reborn, who knows where food comes from in that region. It's definitely best not to think too deeply or to look too closely within the mystery meats and sundries while there.

 

It's like college slop. It's edible, albeit barely, but it'll always be a mystery.

 

Berries can be made into smoothies and shakes. As snacks, I'd imagine that a fair few of them would scratch the surface of fullness, but never fully satisfy it. Fair enough, you can incorporate any feedback that you can receive, or not, as you wish to.

 

I'll be keeping tabs upon your great work as I continue to read it,

 

Valyrian.

 

PS: If there's anything that I hadn't addressed above, please let me know.

 

Edited by Valyrian_Reforged
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good evening! I hope you're all doing well. 

 

It's been a little while, and I had expected to be able to make progress in the story in the past two weeks... But I haven't, much. Summer break is over, and I am now studying with a vengeance (and some impressively irregular hours). So instead I worried about the next fights in game (Serra, Sirius/Sigmund, Steelix, Abra, Noel), tried to plan for them and got the important details wrong -- but never mind. 

 

I'd like to say that the information I've given in my two previous posts isn't entirely canon. They're how I view things at first, but I haven't thought them fully through. But they look consistent enough. 

 

Valyrian -- these are some interesting remarks on food. That may explain why I'm always wary of eating around a US college, when I go there. 🤣

 

Valyrian, regarding the contents of Part 1: well, in the stories I had seen, I had thought the devastation and the challenge level somewhat understated, with the PULSEs looking like early game bosses. But it didn't fit with my vision of the things -- they're literal bioweapons, engines of destruction wreaking havoc on huge areas. In my view, Gabriel isn't (at least at that point -- all bets are off for the late game) the golden hero that will always win effortlessly, so really the question was more: how could it not be a struggle of life or death? 

 

I'm glad I was able to convey all this. 

 

 

Anyway, we're moving on, with another very long chapter, with a title that may or may not be one of the most appropriate ones in the story. It has a lot of dialog that I'm not sure I got quite right, but I suppose that is part of an author's occupational hazards. Also, an offhand comment from about a year ago gets finally fully explained. Enjoy!

 

 

 

Chapter 57: Psy Ops

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

Character rates:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

  • Like 3
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This was kinda a bittersweet chapter, given we know the truth and reason behind the escape from the Orphanage. Can't blame him given how screwed up this place was thanks to Sigmund... 

  On 9/18/2021 at 6:30 PM, Mindlack said:

She was over eighteen, while the boy was barely twelve, but she had enjoyed spending time at the Orphanage with him. He was sensible, mature enough, not too overwhelming. They had made drawings together, learnt from each other's styles. She had taught him chess and they fondly played, his progress mostly matching hers despite the age difference.

Expand  

Despite it does had some good things, but- we all know- it's getting overshadowed by that "practice" called ECT and Sigmund's wrong practice. Not that is already new to us😶

 

  On 9/18/2021 at 6:30 PM, Mindlack said:

"I was worried that it would backfire if I didn't do it." he sniffed. Tears were running from his eyes, now more open than any time before. He couldn't bear to face Laura's disapproving look, and he lowered his eyes. "Plus, I thought it added some authenticity. Especially for someone who loved math -- he would relish the challenge, trust its outcome." Noel's sob was a full shudder.

Expand  

You know I can understand Noel's situation, but it kinda went down hill in the Underground Railnet. Just give him a hug already🧸

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah yeah I know. "You said you were restarting reading like a year ago. What happen?" I'm terrible at reading ok donut judge 🙈

  On 10/31/2019 at 2:27 PM, Mindlack said:

And there's a Gym where the Leader requires people to fight naked in the dark.

Expand  

Luna is that u? What we gonna see, or actually, not see in that battle? 👀

  On 11/27/2019 at 5:40 PM, Mindlack said:

"Well, that's nice. We haven't heard about him for at least a month."

 

Of him? Was the Nurse Joy...

Expand  

Ngl I love it when these kind of things give stuff away cause even smol brain Candy can see they screwed up lol

  On 12/7/2019 at 7:11 PM, Mindlack said:

So she mentioned to me the Candy Shop, in one of Obsidia's largest (and currently most damaged) alleys. 

Expand  

owo

  On 12/7/2019 at 7:11 PM, Mindlack said:

"No false moves either." someone whispered to my ear.

Expand  

That's one big bad cliffhanger lol

I like that you actually upped the stakes in the slums, which makes why Victoria wanted to stop Gabriel earlier make sense. He really ain't the type that could get past some gangs in one piece xP

 

Also I want to self-congratulate myself for reading a good number of chapters on one sitting cause I can rarely do anything for this long without getting distracted lmao *bows* thank you, thank you *bows*

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 9/21/2021 at 10:01 PM, Candy said:

Yeah yeah I know. "You said you were restarting reading like a year ago. What happen?" I'm terrible at reading ok donut judge 🙈

Expand  

 

I'm not judging, I'm very glad that you're reading!

 

  On 9/21/2021 at 10:01 PM, Candy said:

Luna is that u? What we gonna see, or actually, not see in that battle? 👀

Expand  

 

  Quote

Oh, my. Well, be that as it may, it wasn't quite my intention.

Expand  

 

(damn, that makes three people to which this sentence could have applied)

 

I have no plans to feature such a battle. It's probably one of the clumsiest things in the early story that I wrote. But I'm fancying Reborn City as a very good place for rumors to spread (let's say that this anecdote didn't happen to the guy who spoke about it), and there's a (non-immediate) reason why I added this. I'm sure that there are far more skilled ways to, er, fulfill the purpose of this remark (for reasons that should be apparent in a little while), except that I couldn't think of one.

 

  On 9/21/2021 at 10:01 PM, Candy said:

Ngl I love it when these kind of things give stuff away cause even smol brain Candy can see they screwed up lol

owo

Expand  

 

Gabriel isn't always very observant -- he doesn't really know how to do it usefully -- and he won't stand his ground unless he has a very good reason to. I needed something blatant to make him realize something was amiss. And even then, you'll note that the Meteors took the initiative, not him. ^^

 

  On 9/21/2021 at 10:01 PM, Candy said:

That's one big bad cliffhanger lol

I like that you actually upped the stakes in the slums, which makes why Victoria wanted to stop Gabriel earlier make sense. He really ain't the type that could get past some gangs in one piece xP

Expand  

 

I completely agree (although I don't quite remember what Victoria said). It's almost surprising that he made it this far.

 

  On 9/21/2021 at 10:01 PM, Candy said:

Also I want to self-congratulate myself for reading a good number of chapters on one sitting cause I can rarely do anything for this long without getting distracted lmao *bows* thank you, thank you *bows*

Expand  

 

Can I self-congratulate too for writing these chapters so well that they didn't let you get distracted?🤣

Kudos (and thank you) for reading this much in one go, and I hope that you'll find the time and inclination to read on.

 

 

@Evi Crystal I'll reply to you in spoilers, so that Candy does not unwittingly learn about half the plot points before they even get brought up.

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 9/22/2021 at 10:33 AM, Mindlack said:

But I'm fancying Reborn City as a very good place for rumors to spread (let's say that this anecdote didn't happen to the guy who spoke about it), and there's a (non-immediate) reason why I added this.

Expand  

big bummerr but hey that's still fun (not me picturing Gabriel readying himself to take off his clothes, and Luna asks him WTF he's doing 🤡) Coincidentally, I did also kinda imply that, at least among the Karens of Reborn region, the gossips tend to fly about (with some of the wards thinking they had a ghost problem, but it was Vanilla/Pikachu).

  On 9/22/2021 at 10:33 AM, Mindlack said:

And even then, you'll note that the Meteors took the initiative, not him. ^^

Expand  

Yep he was like "Him? I thought she was a her..." and Team Meteor was like "So you've chosen death" and he was like "what is happen?????"

  On 9/22/2021 at 10:33 AM, Mindlack said:

Can I self-congratulate too for writing these chapters so well that they didn't let you get distracted?🤣

Expand  

"You get a self-congratulation, and you get a self-congratulation. EVERYBODY GETS A SELF-CONGRATULATION!!!!"

  • Haha 1
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 9/18/2021 at 6:30 PM, Mindlack said:

Good evening! I hope you're all doing well. 

 

It's been a little while, and I had expected to be able to make progress in the story in the past two weeks... But I haven't, much. Summer break is over, and I am now studying with a vengeance (and some impressively irregular hours). So instead I worried about the next fights in game (Serra, Sirius/Sigmund, Steelix, Abra, Noel), tried to plan for them and got the important details wrong -- but never mind. 

 

I'd like to say that the information I've given in my two previous posts isn't entirely canon. They're how I view things at first, but I haven't thought them fully through. But they look consistent enough. 

 

Valyrian -- these are some interesting remarks on food. That may explain why I'm always wary of eating around a US college, when I go there. 🤣

 

Valyrian, regarding the contents of Part 1: well, in the stories I had seen, I had thought the devastation and the challenge level somewhat understated, with the PULSEs looking like early game bosses. But it didn't fit with my vision of the things -- they're literal bioweapons, engines of destruction wreaking havoc on huge areas. In my view, Gabriel isn't (at least at that point -- all bets are off for the late game) the golden hero that will always win effortlessly, so really the question was more: how could it not be a struggle of life or death? 

 

I'm glad I was able to convey all this. 

 

 

Anyway, we're moving on, with another very long chapter, with a title that may or may not be one of the most appropriate ones in the story. It has a lot of dialog that I'm not sure I got quite right, but I suppose that is part of an author's occupational hazards. Also, an offhand comment from about a year ago gets finally fully explained. Enjoy!

 

 

 

Chapter 57: Psy Ops

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

Character rates:

  Reveal hidden contents

 

Expand  

 

Hi, Mindlack,

 

Thank you for your insights. I shall continue to read this fanfiction and see where Gabriel's journey will lead him. I like how realistic your take upon Gabriel's Pokemon journey is. The main games do not take into account how much or how little the protagonist may or may not want to step in and save the Pokemon world/s.

 

They simply thrust the protagonist headlong into the adventure, danger and drama in spectacular fashion because of their own belief that this is the right thing to do for all and by all. This is what makes Gabriel's reluctance logical, reasonable and understandable, in my opinion.

 

I agree about the Chapter 1 events being understated. I really enjoyed reading about the devastation (that the world wasn't protected from xD) that had been wrought upon the wards and your colourful usage of words such as malignant flora and fauna.

 

You made great use of the world that had been built within Reborn and had fleshed it out magnificently so that it read cleanly and eloquently off the pages to great effect.

 

I had been understandably engrossed within your turns of phrase and by your battles themselves that by chapter's end, I had felt more than somewhat at a loss, yet eager to read more of your work. I have alot to catch up upon in regard to my readthrough of this work of yours, but I do not see my having to catch up at all a chore.

 

In regard to the lateness of your updates, worry not - life delays the rest and the best of us and I imagine that I won't be the first among the fans and the readers of your written works to say that writing as great as your own is well worth the wait.

 

It's easy to feel as though you may have let your audience down via your time away from your keyboard. Know that you have not done so and that you could not do so. Keep up the fantastic work - I'm cheering you from the sidelines, my writer friend.

 

Apologies for my late response. I appreciate your reply. :)

Edited by Valyrian_Reforged
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...